1		% (c) 2009-2024 Lehrstuhl fuer Softwaretechnik und Programmiersprachen,
2		% Heinrich Heine Universitaet Duesseldorf
3		% This software is licenced under EPL 1.0 (http://www.eclipse.org/org/documents/epl-v10.html)
4
5		:- module(b_interpreter_check,[imply_test_boolean_expression/7,
6		equiv_test_boolean_expression/7,
7		equiv_bidrectional_test_boolean_expression/7,
8		get_priority_of_boolean_expression/2, get_priority_of_boolean_expression2/2,
9		b_check_boolean_expression/5,b_check_boolean_expression/7,
10
11		/* some lower-level propagation predicates */
12		imply/3, imply_true/2,
13		b_check_forall_wf/8, b_check_exists_wf/7,
14
15		reify_closure_with_small_cardinality/5,
16
17		register_predicate/6, norm_pred_check/2, norm_expr_check/2,
18
19		conjoin/6, disjoin/6,
20		check_less_than_equal/3
21		]).
22
23		/* A version for checking the truth value of boolean-expressions,
24		the result is instantiated with pred_true/pred_false as soon as the result is known */
25		/* Warning: does not cover all expressions */
26		/* It provides SMT-like performance, for predicates involving arithmetic comparisons (<,...),
27		equality, disequality and membership/not_membership
28		It is not restricted to CNF
29		*/
30
31		:- meta_predicate wd_delay(0,-,-,-).
32		:- meta_predicate wd_delay_block(0,-,-,-,-,-).
33		:- meta_predicate wd_delay_until_needed(-,0).
34		:- meta_predicate wd_delay_until_needed_block(-,-,0).
35
36		:- use_module(debug).
37		:- use_module(self_check).
38		:- use_module(error_manager).
39		:- use_module(b_interpreter,[b_compute_expression/5, b_not_test_boolean_expression/6, b_test_boolean_expression/6, b_test_boolean_expression/4]).
40		:- use_module(kernel_waitflags).
41
42
43		:- use_module(kernel_objects,[less_than_direct/2, less_than_equal_direct/2]).
44
45		:- use_module(kernel_equality).
46
47		:- use_module(tools).
48
49		:- use_module(module_information,[module_info/2]).
50		:- module_info(group,interpreter).
51		:- module_info(description,'This module provides a reified interpreter for certain predicates.').
52
53
54
55
56		:- block imply_test_boolean_expression(-, ?,?,?,?,?,?). % TO DO: pass at least Ai to it
57		imply_test_boolean_expression(PredRes1,PredRes2, RHS,LocalState,State,WF,Ai) :-
58		(PredRes1=PredRes2
59	?	-> b_test_boolean_expression(RHS,LocalState,State,WF,Ai,_)
60		; true
61		).
62
63		:- block equiv_test_boolean_expression(-, ?,?,?,?,?,?).
64		equiv_test_boolean_expression(PredRes,PredRes, RHS,LocalState,State,WF,Ai) :- !,
65		b_test_boolean_expression(RHS,LocalState,State,WF,Ai,_).
66		equiv_test_boolean_expression(_PredRes,_, RHS,LocalState,State,WF,Ai) :-
67	?	b_not_test_boolean_expression(RHS,LocalState,State,WF,Ai,_).
68
69		equiv_bidrectional_test_boolean_expression(PredResLHS,PredResRHS, _LHS,_RHS,_LocalState,_State,WF) :-
70		PredResLHS=PredResRHS,
71	?	(var(PredResLHS)
72		-> % create a choice point to enumerate two possible solutions
73		% important, e.g., for not((y > 0 & y * y > 20) <=> (y * y > 25 & y > 0))
74		get_last_wait_flag(equivalence,WF,LWF),
75		enum_bool(PredResLHS,LWF)
76		; true).
77		:- block enum_bool(-,-).
78		enum_bool(pred_true,_).
79		enum_bool(pred_false,_).
80		/*
81		:- block equiv_bidrectional_test_boolean_expression(-,-, ?,?,?,?,?).
82		equiv_bidrectional_test_boolean_expression(PredResLHS,PredResRHS, LHS,RHS,LocalState,State,WF) :-
83		( PredResLHS == pred_true -> b_test_boolean_expression(RHS,LocalState,State,WF)
84		; PredResLHS == pred_false -> b_not_test_boolean_expression(RHS,LocalState,State,WF)
85		; PredResRHS == pred_true -> b_test_boolean_expression(LHS,LocalState,State,WF)
86		; PredResRHS == pred_false -> b_not_test_boolean_expression(LHS,LocalState,State,WF)
87		; add_error_fail(equiv,'Illegal values: ',equiv_bidrectional_test_boolean_expression(PredResLHS,PredResRHS))
88		).
89		*/
90
91		% return starting priority for binary choice points; should be power of 2
92		get_priority_of_boolean_expression(priority(P),Prio) :- !,
93		% case generated for disjoin by contains_fd_element, and not_in_difference_set_wf,not_in_intersection_set_wf,in_union_set_wf
94		Prio=P.
95		get_priority_of_boolean_expression(b(Expr,_,_Infos),Prio) :- !,
96		% try to estimate a priority for performing a case split upon a predicate
97		% i.e., forcing a predicate Expr to be true/false
98		get_priority_of_boolean_expression2(Expr,Prio).
99		get_priority_of_boolean_expression(E,Prio) :-
100		add_internal_error('Boolean expression not properly wrapped: ',get_priority_of_boolean_expression(E,Prio)),
101		get_priority_of_boolean_expression2(E,Prio).
102
103		:- use_module(bsyntaxtree).
104		get_priority_of_boolean_expression2(truth,1) :- !. %, nl,nl,print('TRUTH in disjunct/conjunct'),nl.
105		get_priority_of_boolean_expression2(falsity,1) :- !. %, nl,nl,print('FALSITY in disjunct/conjunct'),nl.
106		get_priority_of_boolean_expression2(_,R) :-
107		preferences:preference(data_validation_mode,true), % in data validation mode we want to drive enumeration from data values only
108		!, R=4096.
109		get_priority_of_boolean_expression2(_,R) :- !, R=4. % force SMT style case-splitting; was 3 before using get_binary_choice_wait_flag_exp_backoff; raising this to 4 makes test 1358, 49 behave better (baload_R07 recognised possible)
110
111
112
113
114		count_number_of_conjuncts(b(Expr,_,_Infos),Prio) :- !,
115		count_number_of_conjuncts2(Expr,Prio).
116		count_number_of_conjuncts(priority(_),Prio) :- !, Prio=1.
117		count_number_of_conjuncts(B,Prio) :-
118		add_internal_error('Expression not wrapped: ',count_number_of_conjuncts(B,Prio)),Prio=1.
119		count_number_of_conjuncts2(conjunct(A,B),Nr) :- !, count_number_of_conjuncts(A,NA),
120		count_number_of_conjuncts(B,NB), Nr is NA+NB.
121		count_number_of_conjuncts2(norm_conjunct(_,RHS),Res) :- length(RHS,Len),!,
122		Res is Len+1.
123		count_number_of_conjuncts2(negation(A),Nr) :- !, count_number_of_disjuncts(A,Nr).
124		count_number_of_conjuncts2(_,1).
125
126		:- public count_number_of_disjuncts/2. %currently commented out above
127		count_number_of_disjuncts(b(Expr,_,_Infos),Prio) :- !,
128		count_number_of_disjuncts2(Expr,Prio).
129		count_number_of_disjuncts(priority(_),Prio) :- !, Prio=1.
130		count_number_of_disjuncts(B,Prio) :-
131		add_internal_error('Expression not wrapped: ',count_number_of_disjuncts(B,Prio)),Prio=1.
132		count_number_of_disjuncts2(disjunct(A,B),Nr) :- !, count_number_of_disjuncts(A,NA),
133		count_number_of_disjuncts(B,NB), Nr is NA+NB.
134		count_number_of_disjuncts2(norm_disjunct(_,RHS),Res) :- length(RHS,Len),!,
135		Res is Len+1.
136		count_number_of_disjuncts2(negation(A),Nr) :- !, count_number_of_conjuncts(A,Nr).
137		count_number_of_disjuncts2(_,1).
138
139
140
141		% we need to ensure that b_check_boolean_expression does not create a choice point on its own
142
143		b_check_boolean_expression(b(Expr,_,Infos),LS,S,WF,Res) :-
144		(composed(Expr) -> empty_avl(Ai)
145		; Ai = no_avl), % simple expression: no sharing is possible: no need to register expressions
146		create_wfwd_needed(WF,WFD),
147		b_check_boolean_expression2(Expr,Infos,LS,S,WFD,Res,Ai,_).
148
149		composed(negation(_)).
150		composed(conjunct(_,_)).
151		composed(disjunct(_,_)).
152		composed(implication(_,_)).
153		composed(equivalence(_,_)).
154		composed(let_predicate(_,_,_)).
155		composed(lazy_let_pred(_,_,_)).
156
157		b_check_boolean_expression(E,LS,S,WF,Res,Ai,Ao) :-
158		% WFD adds information about WD context: wfwd(WF_store, ExpectedVal, Val,Infos)
159		% when Val becomes nonvar: if Val==ExpectedVal we need the value of E, otherwise it should be discarded
160		create_wfwd_needed(WF,WFD),
161	?	b_check_boolean_expression1(E,LS,S,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao).
162
163		b_check_boolean_expression0(WDE,WDV,Expr,LS,S,WF,Res,Ai,Ao) :-
164		create_wfwd(WF,WDE,WDV,WFD),
165	?	b_check_boolean_expression1(Expr,LS,S,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao).
166
167
168		b_check_boolean_expression1(b(Expr,_,Infos),LS,S,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- get_wd(WFD,WDE,WDV),!,
169		% print('check : '), translate:print_bexpr(b(Expr,pred,Infos)),nl,
170		(nonvar(WDV),WDE \= WDV % the expression is not needed
171		-> Ai=Ao,
172		(var(Res)
173		-> Res=pred_false % set it to false, value does not matter; note: predicate is not reused
174		; true)
175	?	; b_check_boolean_expression2(Expr,Infos,LS,S,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao)).
176		b_check_boolean_expression1(E,LS,S,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :-
177		add_internal_error('Boolean expression not properly wrapped: ',b_check_boolean_expression1(E,LS,S,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao)),
178		b_check_boolean_expression2(E,[],LS,S,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao).
179
180		% normalise conjunction into flat list of conjuncts
181		normalise_conjunct(b(E,_,Info)) --> normalise_conjunct2(E,Info).
182		normalise_conjunct2(conjunct(A,B),_) --> !,normalise_conjunct(A),normalise_conjunct(B).
183		normalise_conjunct2(F,Info) --> [b(F,pred,Info)].
184
185		construct_norm_conjunct(A,b(B,pred,Info)) :- construct_norm_conjunct2(A,B,Info).
186		construct_norm_conjunct2([],truth,[]).
187		construct_norm_conjunct2([H|T],Res,Info) :-
188		(T==[] -> H=b(Res,pred,Info) ; Res=norm_conjunct(H,T),Info=[]).
189		% TO DO: build up member(contains_wd_condition,Infos)
190
191
192		% normalise disjunction into flat list of disjuncts
193		normalise_disjunct(b(E,_,Info)) --> normalise_disjunct2(E,Info).
194		normalise_disjunct2(disjunct(A,B),_) --> !,normalise_disjunct(A),normalise_disjunct(B).
195		normalise_disjunct2(F,Info) --> [b(F,pred,Info)].
196
197		construct_norm_disjunct(A,b(B,pred,Info)) :- construct_norm_disjunct2(A,B,Info).
198		construct_norm_disjunct2([],falsity,[]).
199		construct_norm_disjunct2([H|T],Res,Info) :-
200		(T==[] -> H=b(Res,pred,Info) ; Res=norm_disjunct(H,T),Info=[]).
201
202		can_negate_expression(b(Expr,pred,I),b(NExpr,pred,I)) :- can_negate2(Expr,NExpr).
203		can_negate2(equal(A,B),not_equal(A,B)).
204		can_negate2(not_equal(A,B),equal(A,B)).
205		can_negate2(member(A,B),not_member(A,B)).
206		can_negate2(not_member(A,B),member(A,B)).
207		can_negate2(subset(A,B),not_subset(A,B)).
208		can_negate2(not_subset(A,B),subset(A,B)).
209		can_negate2(subset_strict(A,B),not_subset_strict(A,B)).
210		can_negate2(not_subset_strict(A,B),subset_strict(A,B)).
211		can_negate2(greater_equal(A,B),less(A,B)).
212		can_negate2(less(A,B),greater_equal(A,B)).
213		can_negate2(less_equal(A,B),greater(A,B)).
214		can_negate2(greater(A,B),less_equal(A,B)).
215		can_negate2(less_real(A,B),less_equal_real(B,A)).
216		can_negate2(less_equal_real(A,B),less_real(B,A)).
217
218		b_check_boolean_expression2(truth,_,_,_,_WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,Res=pred_true, Ai=Ao.
219		b_check_boolean_expression2(falsity,_,_,_,_WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,Res=pred_false, Ai=Ao.
220		b_check_boolean_expression2(negation(BExpr),_,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,
221		(can_negate_expression(BExpr,NBExpr)
222		-> /* avoid introducing negate propagator; maybe not necessary */
223		b_check_boolean_expression1(NBExpr,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao)
224		; negate(NR,Res),
225		b_check_boolean_expression1(BExpr,LocalState,State,WFD,NR,Ai,Ao)).
226		b_check_boolean_expression2(conjunct(LHS,RHS),CInfo,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,
227		normalise_conjunct2(conjunct(LHS,RHS),CInfo,NormRes,[]),
228		construct_norm_conjunct2(NormRes,NC,Info),
229	?	b_check_boolean_expression2(NC,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao).
230		b_check_boolean_expression2(norm_conjunct(LHS,RHS),_,LocalState,State,wfwd(WF,WDE,WDV,_),Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,
231		construct_norm_conjunct(RHS,NC),
232		conjoin(LR,RR,Res,LHS,NC,WF),
233		create_wfwd(WF,WDE,WDV,WFD),
234	?	b_check_boolean_expression1(LHS,LocalState,State,WFD,LR,Ai,Aii),
235		propagagate_wfwd(WDE,WDV,GuardFlag,LR,pred_false), % if WDE/=WDV then set GuardFlag to pred_false; indicating to RHS that it is not needed also
236	?	b_check_boolean_expression0(pred_true,GuardFlag,NC,LocalState,State,WF,RR,Aii,Ao).
237		b_check_boolean_expression2(implication(LHS,RHS),_,LocalState,State,wfwd(WF,WDE,WDV,_),Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,
238		imply(LR,RR,Res),
239		create_wfwd(WF,WDE,WDV,WFD),
240		b_check_boolean_expression1(LHS,LocalState,State,WFD,LR,Ai,Aii),
241		propagagate_wfwd(WDE,WDV,GuardFlag,LR,pred_false),
242	?	b_check_boolean_expression0(pred_true,GuardFlag,RHS,LocalState,State,WF,RR,Aii,Ao).
243		b_check_boolean_expression2(equivalence(LHS,RHS),_,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !, equiv(LR,RR,Res),
244		b_check_boolean_expression1(LHS,LocalState,State,WFD,LR,Ai,Aii),
245		b_check_boolean_expression1(RHS,LocalState,State,WFD,RR,Aii,Ao).
246		b_check_boolean_expression2(disjunct(LHS,RHS),CInfo,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,
247		normalise_disjunct2(disjunct(LHS,RHS),CInfo,NormRes,[]),
248		construct_norm_disjunct2(NormRes,NC,Info),
249		b_check_boolean_expression2(NC,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao).
250		b_check_boolean_expression2(norm_disjunct(LHS,RHS),_,LocalState,State,wfwd(WF,WDE,WDV,_),Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,
251		construct_norm_disjunct(RHS,NC),
252		disjoin(LR,RR,Res,LHS,NC,WF),
253		create_wfwd(WF,WDE,WDV,WFD),
254		b_check_boolean_expression1(LHS,LocalState,State,WFD,LR,Ai,Aii),
255		propagagate_wfwd(WDE,WDV,GuardFlag,LR,pred_true),
256		b_check_boolean_expression0(pred_false,GuardFlag,NC,LocalState,State,WF,RR,Aii,Ao).
257		b_check_boolean_expression2(let_predicate(Ids,AssignmentExprs,Pred),_Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,
258		wd_set_up_localstate_for_let(Ids,AssignmentExprs,LocalState,State,LetState,WFD),
259		Ao=Ai, % anything cached inside the LET may depend on Ids and should not be reused outside of LET, see test 2397
260		empty_avl(InnerAi), % we can only reuse predicates inside if Ids are fresh, see test 2398
261		b_check_boolean_expression1(Pred,LetState,State,WFD,Res,InnerAi,_).
262		b_check_boolean_expression2(lazy_let_pred(Id,AssignmentExpr,Pred),_I,LocalState,State,wfwd(WF,WDE,WDV,_),Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,
263		set_up_localstate([Id],[(Trigger,IdValue)],LocalState,LetState),
264		b_interpreter:lazy_compute_expression(Trigger,AssignmentExpr,LocalState,State,IdValue,WF,Ai),
265		create_wfwd(WF,WDE,WDV,WFD),
266		b_check_boolean_expression1(Pred,LetState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao). % Lazy lets always unique, we can pass Ai
267		b_check_boolean_expression2(lazy_lookup_pred(Id),Info,LocalState,_State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !, Ai=Ao,
268		store:lookup_value_for_existing_id(Id,LocalState,(Trigger,Value)), % should normally only occur in LocalState; value introduced by lazy_let
269		wd_delay(((Trigger,Value) = (pred_true,Res)),
270		Res,b(lazy_lookup_pred(Id),pred,Info),WFD).
271		b_check_boolean_expression2(value(V),_Info,_LocalState,_State,_WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !, % this can occur when lazy_lookup_pred gets compiled by b_compiler
272		Res=V,Ai=Ao.
273		b_check_boolean_expression2(not_equal(LHS,RHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,
274		(negate_equal_false(LHS,RHS,LHS1,RHS1)
275		-> /* X/=FALSE equivalent to X=TRUE */
276		b_check_boolean_expression3_pos(equal(LHS1,RHS1),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao)
277	?	; b_check_boolean_expression3_neg(equal(LHS,RHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao)
278		).
279		b_check_boolean_expression2(equal(LHS,RHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,
280		(negate_equal_false(LHS,RHS,LHS1,RHS1)
281		-> RHS1=b(boolean_true,boolean,[]), /* X/=FALSE equivalent to X=TRUE */
282		b_check_boolean_expression3_neg(equal(LHS1,RHS1),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao)
283	?	; b_check_boolean_expression3_pos(equal(LHS,RHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao)
284		).
285		b_check_boolean_expression2(not_member(LHS,RHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,
286		b_check_boolean_expression3_neg(member(LHS,RHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao).
287		b_check_boolean_expression2(not_subset(LHS,RHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,
288		b_check_boolean_expression3_neg(subset(LHS,RHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao).
289		b_check_boolean_expression2(not_subset_strict(LHS,RHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,
290		b_check_boolean_expression3_neg(subset_strict(LHS,RHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao).
291		b_check_boolean_expression2(greater(LHS,RHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,
292		b_check_boolean_expression3_pos(less(RHS,LHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao).
293		b_check_boolean_expression2(greater_equal(LHS,RHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,
294		b_check_boolean_expression3_neg(less(LHS,RHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao).
295		b_check_boolean_expression2(less_equal(LHS,RHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :- !,
296		b_check_boolean_expression3_neg(less(RHS,LHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao).
297		b_check_boolean_expression2(Pred,Infos,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :-
298	?	b_check_boolean_expression3_pos(Pred,Infos,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao).
299
300
301		% check whether one of the two arguments is FALSE
302		% translate X/=FALSE -> X=TRUE for normalisation purposes
303		negate_equal_false(b(boolean_false,boolean,_),E,E,b(boolean_true,boolean,[])).
304		negate_equal_false(E,b(boolean_false,boolean,_),E,b(boolean_true,boolean,[])).
305
306		b_check_boolean_expression3_pos(Pred,Infos,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,Ao) :-
307		%print(register_predicate(WFD)),nl,portray_avl(Ai),nl,
308		register_predicate_wfd(WFD,Pred,Infos,Res,Reused,Ai,Ai2),
309		(Reused=true
310		-> Ao=Ai2 % , print(reused_pred(Res,WFD,Infos)),nl
311	?	; b_check_boolean_expression4(Pred,Infos,LocalState,State,WFD,Ok,Res),
312		(Ok=ok_to_store -> Ao=Ai2 ; Ao=Ai)
313		).
314
315		b_check_boolean_expression3_neg(Pred,Infos,LocalState,State,WFD,NegRes,Ai,Ao) :-
316		%print(register_neg_predicate(WFD,Infos,Pred)),nl,
317		register_predicate_wfd(WFD,Pred,Infos,Res,Reused,Ai,Ai2), negate(Res,NegRes),
318		(Reused=true
319		-> Ao=Ai2
320	?	; b_check_boolean_expression4(Pred,Infos,LocalState,State,WFD,Ok,Res),
321		(Ok=ok_to_store -> Ao=Ai2 ; Ao=Ai)
322		).
323
324		% Register a new predicate in the AVL tree if either forced or non-WD condition inside
325		register_predicate_wfd(_,_,_,_,false,Ai,Ao) :- Ai = no_avl,!, Ai=Ao.
326		register_predicate_wfd(_,_Pred,_Infos,_,false,Ai,Ao) :-
327		preferences:preference(use_common_subexpression_elimination,true),
328		preferences:preference(use_common_subexpression_also_for_predicates,true),
329		preferences:preference(disprover_mode,false), % there are still a few things detected here that CSE does not detect (=FALSE,=TRUE,...)
330		!, % CSE already statically detects these ( all of the time !?)
331		Ai=Ao.
332		register_predicate_wfd(WFWD,Pred,Infos,PredTruthVar,Reused,Ai,Ao) :-
333		get_wd(WFWD,A,B),
334		(A==B -> register_predicate_aux(Pred,PredTruthVar,Reused,Ai,Ao) % it will be evaluated; we can share it
335		; nonmember(contains_wd_condition,Infos) -> register_predicate_aux(Pred,PredTruthVar,Reused,Ai,Ao)
336		% Pred is not guaranteed to be evaluated: WD-condition + not in forced WFD context (beware of exists!)
337		; register_predicate_aux(Pred,PredTruthVar,true,Ai,Ao) -> Reused=true % the predicate is already stored
338		% Note: as predicate is already stored; no problem with WD; relevant for test 1959
339		; Ai=Ao, Reused=false % not guaranteed to be evaluated: WD-condition + not in forced WFD context
340		% ,print('NOT REGISTERING: '), translate:print_bexpr(Pred),nl
341		).
342
343		:- assert_must_succeed((E=empty, %avl:empty_avl(E),
344		A=b(value(_VAR),integer,[]),
345		b_interpreter_check:register_predicate(equal(A,A),[],pred_true,Reused,E,A1),
346		Reused==false, A1==empty)). % ensure we do not store non-var expressions
347		:- assert_must_succeed((E=empty, %avl:empty_avl(E),
348		A=b(value(int(1)),integer,[]),
349		b_interpreter_check:register_predicate(equal(A,A),[],pred_true,Reused,E,A1),
350		Reused==false, A1 \= empty, B=b(value(_),integer,[]),
351		b_interpreter_check:register_predicate(equal(B,B),[],pred_true,Reuse2,A1,A2),
352		Reuse2==false, A2==A1)). % ensure we do not look up non-var expressions
353		:- assert_must_succeed((E=empty, %avl:empty_avl(E),
354		A=b(value(int(1)),integer,[]),
355		b_interpreter_check:register_predicate(equal(A,A),[info1],pred_true,Reused,E,A1),
356		Reused==false,
357		b_interpreter_check:register_predicate(equal(A,A),[info2],pred_true,Reuse2,A1,A2),
358		Reuse2==true, A2==A1)). % ensure registering works
359
360		% Register a new predicate in the AVL tree (for outside callers like b_interpreter.pl)
361		register_predicate(Pred,_Infos,NegPredTruthVar,Reused,Ai,Ao) :- negate_pred(Pred,NegPred),!,
362		%print(negating),nl,
363		negate(PredTruthVar,NegPredTruthVar),
364		register_predicate_aux(NegPred,PredTruthVar,Reused,Ai,Ao).
365		register_predicate(Pred,_Infos,PredTruthVar,Reused,Ai,Ao) :-
366		register_predicate_aux(Pred,PredTruthVar,Reused,Ai,Ao).
367
368		negate_typed_pred(b(A,pred,_),NegA) :- negate_pred(A,NegA).
369		negate_pred(equal(A,B),equal(AA,TRUE)) :- negate_equal_false(A,B,AA,TRUE).
370		negate_pred(not_equal(A,B),equal(A,B)). % TO DO: we should check negate_equal_false
371		negate_pred(not_member(A,B),member(A,B)).
372		negate_pred(not_subset(A,B),subset(A,B)).
373		negate_pred(not_subset_strict(A,B),subset_strict(A,B)).
374		negate_pred(greater_equal(A,B),less(A,B)).
375		negate_pred(less_equal(A,B),less(B,A)).
376		negate_pred(negation(b(A,pred,_)),A).
377
378		% to do: detect convert_bool(Pred) = X and register Pred?
379		register_predicate_aux(Pred,_PredTruthVar,Reused,Ai,Ao) :- do_not_store_pred(Pred),
380		!,
381		Ai=Ao, Reused=false.
382		register_predicate_aux(Pred,PredTruthVar,Reused,Ai,Ao) :- check_pred_truth_var(PredTruthVar),
383		norm_pred_check(Pred,NPred), % We could store this information in the info field computed by ast_cleanup ?
384		(%too_simple(NPred) -> Reused=false, Ao=Ai ; %% even for simple equalities it actually pays off !
385		reuse_predicate(NPred,Var,Ai)
386		-> % nl,print(reusing(NPred,Var)),nl, %%
387		PredTruthVar=Var,Ao=Ai, Reused=true
388		; add_predicate(NPred,PredTruthVar,Ai,Ao), Reused=false
389		%,nl,print(not_reusing(NPred)),nl
390		).
391
392		check_pred_truth_var(X) :- var(X),!.
393		check_pred_truth_var(pred_true) :- !.
394		check_pred_truth_var(pred_false) :- !.
395		check_pred_truth_var(X) :- add_internal_error('Illegal Predicate Truth Value: ',check_pred_truth_var(X)).
396
397		:- use_module(kernel_tools,[ground_bexpr/1]).
398		do_not_store_pred(external_pred_call(_P,_)) :- !. % expcept maybe LESS, CHOOSE,... we could check performs_io
399		do_not_store_pred(B) :-
400		(ground_bexpr(b(B,pred,[]))
401		% TO DO: improve performance: marking bexpr with potential non-ground value(.) terms inside
402		% maybe avoid registering predicates with very large values inside
403		% avoid registering predicate if it is the only one in a closure
404		-> fail
405		; true %print('-> Not storing: '),translate:print_bexpr(b(B,pred,[])),nl
406		).
407
408
409		% Quantifier Expansion
410
411		b_check_forall_wf(Parameters,LHS,RHS,Info,LocalState,State,WF,PredRes) :-
412		create_wfwd_needed(WF,WFD), % we expect it to be in a context where the value will be needed
413		b_check_forall_wfwd(Parameters,LHS,RHS,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,PredRes).
414		b_check_forall_wfwd(_Parameters,LHS,RHS,_Info,_LocalState,_State,_WFD,PredRes) :-
415		(is_falsity(LHS) ; is_truth(RHS)),!, % quantifier always true
416		PredRes = pred_true.
417		b_check_forall_wfwd(Parameters,LHS,RHS,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,PredRes) :-
418	?	small_quantifier_cardinality(Parameters,LHS,LHS1,LHSRest),
419		%print(expand(forall(Parameters))),nl,
420		expand_quantifier(Parameters,LHS1,List,forall,Info), %print(List),nl,
421		Body = b(implication(LHSRest,RHS),pred,Info),% translate:print_bexpr(Body),nl,
422		get_wf(WFD,WF),
423		check_expanded_forall_quantifier(List,Body, LocalState, State,WF,WFD,PredRes).
424		% TO DO: if not small_quantifier_cardinality: b_check_boolean_expression4_delay
425
426
427		b_check_exists_wf(Parameters,Body,Info,LocalState,State,WF,PredRes) :-
428		create_wfwd_needed(WF,WFD), % we expect it to be in a context where the value will be needed
429		b_check_exists_wfwd(Parameters,Body,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,_,PredRes).
430		b_check_exists_wfwd(Parameters,Body,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,ok_to_store,PredRes) :-
431		% could be generalised to take into consideration domain as restricted by Body
432	?	small_quantifier_cardinality(Parameters,Body,LHS,RHS),!,
433		% print(expanding_check_exists(_Card,Parameters)),nl, % portray_waitflags(WF),
434		expand_quantifier(Parameters,LHS,List,exists,Info),
435		% now compute a priority for the disjunction based on the number of case splits
436		% relevant for tests 1358, 1746
437		length(List,Len), % Note: if Len=1: the body must be true; no disjoin will be set up
438		get_pow2_binary_choice_priority(Len,Prio),
439		% if Len=2 -> we actually have just two possibilities T,_ and F,T; but we want Prio to start at 4 ?
440		% if Len=3 -> we have T,_,_ ; F,T,_ ; F,F,T less possibilites if disjoin enumerated from left-to-right; TO DO: should we lower the priority taking this into account ?
441		% TO DO: maybe we could directly set up an n-ary disjoin predicate;
442		% if one disjunct true; remove case-splits on other disjuncts
443		get_wf(WFD,WF),
444		check_expanded_exists_quantifier(List,Prio,RHS, LocalState, State,WF,WFD,PredRes).
445		b_check_exists_wfwd(Parameters,Body,Infos,LocalState,State,wfwd(WF,WDE,WDV,ContextInfo),do_not_store,PredRes) :-
446		% the above reification has not worked; we now "pretend" that reification worked
447		% and introduce a delayed choice point
448		% do_not_store means that the predicate result should not be re-used somewhere else, because
449		% as the predicate evaluation is delayed it may later not be needed and not evaluated, cf test 2404
450		ContextInfo \= outer_wfwd_context, % at the outer-level interpreter expects reification succeeds only if
451		% at least top-level operator was reified deterministically,
452		% important for tests 1074, 1338, 1358, 1915 with this clause enabled
453		% test 305 #x.(x + x = 1000) now works, but not 1739 (timeout)
454		reify_inner_exists_non_deterministically, % hence we currently only use it in data validation mode
455		% here we enumerate reification variables with a much lower priority (data driven enumeration)
456		% (see get_binary_choice_wait_flag_exp_backoff)
457		% this clause relevant for 0323/CCSL/TYPES_AUTORISES_RVF3_GEN__MRGA.mch
458		Pred = exists(Parameters,Body),
459		perfmessage(reify,reifiying_inner_exists_non_deterministically(Parameters),Infos),
460		b_check_boolean_expression4_delay(WDE,WDV,Pred,Infos,LocalState,State,WF,PredRes).
461
462		% true if we allow reification of exists which cannot be expanded
463		% by delayed non-det enumeration (of pred_false, pred_true) if exists is not at top-level
464		reify_inner_exists_non_deterministically :- preferences:preference(data_validation_mode,true).
465
466
467		:- use_module(b_enumerate, [b_tighter_enumerate_values_in_ctxt/3]).
468		expand_quantifier(Parameters,Pred,ListOfNewLocalStates,QuantKind,Span) :-
469		% at the moment LS,State not really needed; only necessary if non-compiled Pred can be used
470		% also: feeding in any non-bound variables in LocalState or State would cause problems in findall !
471		findall(ParLocalState,
472		(b_interpreter:set_up_typed_localstate(Parameters,ParaValues,ParamTypedVals,
473		[],ParLocalState,all_solutions),
474		kernel_waitflags:init_wait_flags_with_call_stack(WF,
475		[quantifier_call(QuantKind,Parameters,ParaValues,Span)]),
476		b_test_boolean_expression(Pred,[],ParLocalState,WF),
477		b_tighter_enumerate_values_in_ctxt(ParamTypedVals,Pred,WF),
478		kernel_waitflags:ground_wait_flags(WF)),
479		ListOfNewLocalStates).
480
481		% a version which ensures that we have unique solutions of the bindings
482		expand_quantifier_normalised(Parameters,Pred,ListOfNewLocalStates,QuantKind,Span) :-
483		expand_quantifier(Parameters,Pred,List,QuantKind,Span),
484		normalise_local_states(List,NList),
485		sort(NList,ListOfNewLocalStates). % will remove duplicates
486
487		normalise_local_states([],[]).
488		normalise_local_states([State|T],[NS|NT]) :-
489		convert_bindings_to_avl(State,NS),
490		normalise_local_states(T,NT).
491
492		:- use_module(custom_explicit_sets,[convert_to_avl/2]).
493		convert_bindings_to_avl([],[]).
494		convert_bindings_to_avl([bind(Var,Val)|T],[bind(Var,NVal)|NT]) :-
495		(convert_to_avl(Val,NVal) -> true ; add_internal_error('Cannot normalise:',Val),fail),
496		convert_bindings_to_avl(T,NT).
497
498		check_expanded_forall_quantifier([], _Body, _LS, _State,_WF,_WFD,Res) :-
499		Res=pred_true.
500		check_expanded_forall_quantifier([LS1|TLS], Body, LS, State,WF,WFD,Res) :-
501		conjoin(Res1,TRes,Res,Body,Body,WF),
502		empty_avl(InnerAi), % TO DO: maybe use no_avl ?
503		append(LS1,LS,InnerLS),
504		% Note: we do not need to guard against wd-definition from other instances inside a quantified expression
505		% either all conjuncts can be evaluated or none
506		% print(expand_forall(WFD)), translate:print_bexpr(Body),nl,
507		b_check_boolean_expression1(Body,InnerLS,State,WFD,Res1,InnerAi,_Aii),
508		%instantiate_wfwd_result(WDE,WDV,Res1),
509		check_expanded_forall_quantifier(TLS,Body,LS,State,WF,WFD,TRes).
510
511		/*
512		:- block instantiate_wfwd_result(?,-,-).
513		% instantiate a boolean variable in case it is no longer needed and not set by something else
514		instantiate_wfwd_result(WDE,WDV,Res) :-
515		(nonvar(Res) -> true
516		; WDE==WDV -> true
517		; Res = pred_false). */
518
519		check_expanded_exists_quantifier([], _, _Body, _LS, _State,_WF,_WFD,Res) :-
520		Res=pred_false.
521		check_expanded_exists_quantifier([LS1|TLS], Priority, Body, LS, State,WF,WFD,Res) :-
522		(TLS = [] -> Res=Res1
523		; disjoin(Res1,TRes,Res,priority(Priority),priority(Priority),WF)), % was using Body instead of priority(Priority)
524		empty_avl(InnerAi), % TO DO: maybe use no_avl ?
525		append(LS1,LS,InnerLS),
526		b_check_boolean_expression1(Body,InnerLS,State,WFD,Res1,InnerAi,_Aii),
527		% Note: we do not need to guard against wd-definition from other instances inside a quantified expression
528		check_expanded_exists_quantifier(TLS,Priority,Body,LS,State,WF,WFD,TRes).
529
530
531		:- use_module(library(lists),[maplist/4]).
532		% try and convert a closure into a list of 0/1 variables for each potential element
533		reify_closure_with_small_cardinality(P,T,Body, WF,ReifiedList) :- %print(try(P)),nl,
534		maplist(create_typed_id,P,T,Parameters),
535		small_quantifier_cardinality(Parameters,Body,LHS,RHS,350,25000), % TO DO: how to choose these parameters ?
536		% for card({x|x:1..n & x mod 3=0})=c & n=24000 -> 340 ms with reification; 320 ms without; n=74000 : 1020 ms without, 1160 with reification
537		% but there is a big difference for card({x|x:1..n & x mod 3=0 & x<10}) with n=74000 : 0 ms without reification, 1580 with; n=500: 20 ms with reification; n=250: 10 ms with reification
538		expand_quantifier_normalised(Parameters,LHS,List,comprehension_set,Body),
539		% important to normalise and have unique solutions for cardinality reification,
540		% see tests 639, 640 for card(POW(SS)-{{}}) with SS full set
541		create_wfwd_needed(WF,WFD), % is this ok ??
542	?	reifiy_list(List,RHS,WFD,ReifiedList).
543
544
545
546		reifiy_list([], _Body,_WFD,[]).
547		reifiy_list([LS1|TLS], Body,WFD,[Res_01|TRes]) :-
548		empty_avl(InnerAi),
549	?	b_check_boolean_expression1(Body,LS1,[],WFD,Res1_pred,InnerAi,_Aii),
550		prop_pred_01(Res1_pred,Res_01),
551		%format(' reify ~w : ~w~n',[Res_01,LS1]),
552		% Note: we do not need to guard against wd-definition from other instances inside a quantified expression
553		reifiy_list(TLS,Body,WFD,TRes).
554
555
556
557		:- use_module(library(lists),[select/3]).
558
559		% check if Body produces a small cardinality for the paramters Par
560		% if yes: the predicates constraining Par are put into LHS, the rest into RHS
561		% also: LHS must ensure that ground values are produced for Par and that we can enumerate with a separate WF (in expand_quantifier)
562		small_quantifier_cardinality(Par,Body,LHS,RHS) :-
563		%preferences:preference(solver_strength,SS), NL is 10+SS, SMTL is 40+SS,
564		NL=10,SMTL=40,
565	?	small_quantifier_cardinality(Par,Body,LHS,RHS,NL,SMTL). % was 10,35; raising it to 10,41 makes tests 1441, 1442 fail due to expansion of exists; raising it to 16,50 makes test 1112 fail; TO DO: investigate
566		small_quantifier_cardinality(Par,Body,LHS,RHS,NormalLimit,SMTLimit) :-
567		conjunction_to_list(Body,BodyList),
568		def_get_texpr_ids(Par,AllParas),
569	?	small_quantifier_cardinality_aux(Par,AllParas,BodyList,_UpBoundOnSize,LLHS,LRHS,NormalLimit,SMTLimit),
570		conjunct_predicates_with_pos_info(LLHS,LHS),
571		conjunct_predicates_with_pos_info(LRHS,RHS).
572
573		is_membership_or_eq(b(P,pred,Info),TLHS,RHS,Info) :- is_mem_aux(P,TLHS,RHS).
574		is_mem_aux(member(TLHS,b(RHS,_,_)),TLHS,RHS).
575		%is_mem_aux(subset(SONE,b(RHS,_,_)),TLHS,RHS) :- singleton_set_extension(SONE,TLHS).
576		is_mem_aux(equal(TLHS,b(value(V),_,_)),TLHS,value([V])). % x = V is the same as x:{V}
577		%TODO: use :- use_module(bsyntaxtree,[is_membership_or_equality/3]). % will create set_extension
578
579		% do not rely on size for anything: it is just an upper bound on the size; the actual size could be smaller
580		small_quantifier_cardinality_aux([],_,Body,Size,LHS,RHS,_,_) :- !,
581		LHS=[],RHS=Body,Size=1.
582		small_quantifier_cardinality_aux(Parameters,AllParas,[LHS|TBody],FullSize,FullLHS,FullRHS,NormalLimit,SMTLimit) :-
583		is_membership_or_eq(LHS,SID,MemRHS,Info),
584	?	constrains_ID(SID,AllParas,Parameters,RestParameters,SkelVal,SkelToUnify,BindList), % we could check RestParameters /= Parameters
585		% TO DO: we could also allow parameter to be constrained twice x: 1..100 & x: {...} ?
586		(is_small_set(MemRHS,Size,NormalLimit,SMTLimit,Info) % we have a small set of ground values: we can evaluate LHS to expand the quantifier/set_comprehension for the parameters occuring in LHS
587		-> FullLHS = [LHS|RestLHS],FullRHS = RestRHS
588		; infer_ground_membership(MemRHS,SID,SkelVal,SkelToUnify,BindList,NormalLimit,SMTLimit, Size,InferredLHS) ->
589		% we have inferred a superset InferredLHS of MemRHS which is small and known
590		FullLHS = [InferredLHS|RestLHS], % we have added an inferred membership constraint
591		FullRHS = [LHS|RestRHS]), % the original membership LHS still needs to be checked later, after expansion of the quantifier
592		!,
593		% we select LHS to be included in FullLHS and mark parameter ID as constrained
594		small_quantifier_cardinality_aux(RestParameters,AllParas,TBody,RestSize,RestLHS,RestRHS,NormalLimit,SMTLimit),
595		FullSize is Size*RestSize,
596		is_small_size(FullSize,NormalLimit,SMTLimit, Parameters).
597		small_quantifier_cardinality_aux(Parameters,AllParas,[H|Rest],FullSize,RestLHS,[H|RestRHS],NormalLimit,SMTLimit) :- !,
598		% skip the conjunct H
599	?	small_quantifier_cardinality_aux(Parameters,AllParas,Rest,FullSize,RestLHS,RestRHS,NormalLimit,SMTLimit).
600		small_quantifier_cardinality_aux(Parameters,_AllParas,Body,ParCard,[],Body,NormalLimit,SMTLimit) :-
601		% if the remaining parameter type cardinality is small: just use "truth" as body; will instantiate parameters
602	?	b_interpreter:parameter_list_cardinality(Parameters,ParCard),
603		is_small_size(ParCard,NormalLimit,SMTLimit, Parameters).
604
605		% try and extract a ground superset (InferredLHS) of the RHS (ID:RHS) which constrains ID
606		infer_ground_membership(value(List),SID,SkelVal,SkelToUnify,BindList,NormalLimit,SMTLimit, Size,InferredLHS) :-
607		!,
608		% the List is probably not ground; let's try and see if we can extract ground matches for the parameters at least; see test 1627 (s=1..20 & x: s-->BOOL & card({t|t|->TRUE:x}):18..19)
609		extract_bind_list(BindList,LHSTerm,RHSValue),
610		has_bounded_ground_matches(List,SkelVal,SkelToUnify,RHSValue,MatchedValues,1,NrMatches), % TO DO: provide SMTLimit as upper limit
611		NrMatches = Size,
612		is_small_size(Size,NormalLimit,SMTLimit, SID),
613		get_texpr_type(LHSTerm,LHSTermType),
614		InferredLHS = b(member(LHSTerm,b(value(MatchedValues),set(LHSTermType),[])),pred,[generated]).
615		infer_ground_membership(Set,SID,SkelVal,SkelToUnify,BindList,NormalLimit,SMTLimit,Size,InferredLHS) :-
616	?	superset(Set,SuperSet),
617		% e.g., if ID: {1} /\ x -> InferredLHS = {1} and we will add ID : {1} to the LHS of the quantifier and keep ID : {1} /\ x as the RHS
618		infer_ground_mem_aux(SuperSet,SID,SkelVal,SkelToUnify,BindList,NormalLimit,SMTLimit,Size,InferredLHS).
619
620
621		superset(intersection(A,B),Set) :- (Set=A ; Set=B). % Set /\ X <: Set
622		superset(set_subtraction(Set,_),Set). % Set \ X <: Set
623		superset(domain_restriction(_,Set),Set). % X <| Set <: Set
624		superset(domain_subtraction(_,Set),Set). % X <<| Set <: Set
625		superset(range_subtraction(Set,_),Set). % Set |> X <: Set
626		superset(range_restriction(Set,_),Set). % Set |>> X <: Set
627
628		infer_ground_mem_aux(b(Set,T,I),SID,SkelVal,SkelToUnify,BindList,NormalLimit,SMTLimit, Size,InferredLHS) :-
629		(is_small_set(Set,Size,NormalLimit,SMTLimit,I)
630		-> InferredLHS = b(member(SID,b(Set,T,I)),pred,[generated])
631		; infer_ground_membership(Set,SID,SkelVal,SkelToUnify,BindList,NormalLimit,SMTLimit, Size,InferredLHS)).
632
633		:- use_module(bsyntaxtree, [create_couple/3]).
634		% extract result of constrains_ID BindList into an Expression-Tuple for new membership constraint and a value that will be put into a value(List)
635		extract_bind_list([TID/Val],TID,Val) :- !.
636		extract_bind_list([TID/Val|BList],Couple,(Val,RestVal)) :-
637		create_couple(TID,RestExpr,Couple),
638		extract_bind_list(BList,RestExpr,RestVal).
639
640		:- use_module(kernel_tools,[can_match/2]).
641		% check if we can find a bounded / fixed number of ground matches for Skeleton Value in List
642		has_bounded_ground_matches(Var,_,_,_, _,_,_) :- var(Var),!.
643		has_bounded_ground_matches([],_SkelVal,_SkelToUnify,_,[],LenAcc,LenAcc).
644		has_bounded_ground_matches([H|T],SkelVal,SkelToUnify,ValueToStore,Matches,LenAcc,LenRes) :-
645		(can_match(H,SkelVal) -> copy_term((SkelToUnify,ValueToStore),(H,HValueToStore)),
646		ground_value(HValueToStore),
647		Matches = [HValueToStore|MT],
648		A1 is LenAcc+1 ; Matches=MT,A1=LenAcc),
649		has_bounded_ground_matches(T,SkelVal,SkelToUnify,ValueToStore,MT,A1,LenRes).
650
651		% check if the Expr contains ID, i.e., matching Expr with an element of a set will also instantiate and determine TID
652		% TO DO: also accept other patterns: records, sets?,....
653
654		% SkeletonToUnify: a skeleton that can be used to unify with any value and extracts value in BindList
655		constrains_ID(b(E,_,_),AllParas,Parameters,RestParameters,SkeletonValue,SkeletonToUnify,BindList) :-
656	?	constrains_ID_aux(E,AllParas,Parameters,RestParameters,SkeletonValue,SkeletonToUnify,BindList).
657		constrains_ID_aux(couple(A,B),AllParas,Parameters,RestParameters,(V1,V2),(Skel1,Skel2),Bind) :-
658		constrains_ID(A,AllParas,Parameters,Rest1,V1,Skel1,Bind1),
659		constrains_ID(B,AllParas,Rest1,RestParameters,V2,Skel2,Bind2),
660		append(Bind1,Bind2,Bind). % TO DO: use DCGs
661		constrains_ID_aux(rec(F),AllParas,Parameters,RestParameters,record(SkelV),record(SkelU),Bind) :-
662	?	constrains_ID_fields(F,AllParas,Parameters,RestParameters,SkelV,SkelU,Bind).
663		constrains_ID_aux(identifier(ID),AllParas,Parameters,RestParameters,_SkelV,SkelU,Bind) :-
664		% TO DO: allow same id to appear multiple times in expression + allow to re-use parameters in another conjunct
665	?	(select(TID,Parameters,RestParameters), get_texpr_id(TID,ID)
666		-> Bind = [TID/SkelU]
667	?	; member(ID,AllParas), % we have already used/bound ID; we will use first occurence for skeleton/bind; this one is simply ignored
668		% TO DO: we could try and see whether using the second occurence gives a better result
669		RestParameters=Parameters, Bind=[]
670		).
671		constrains_ID_aux(value(V),_AllParas,P,P,V,_,[]) :- ground_value(V).% if not ground value we may not be able to compute all possible values for ID
672		constrains_ID_aux(boolean_true,_AllParas,P,P,pred_true,pred_true,[]). % needed ?? everything is compiled anway ?
673		constrains_ID_aux(boolean_false,_AllParas,P,P,pred_false,pred_false,[]). % needed ?? everything is compiled anway ?
674		% Below: allow any other expression as long as it only uses AllParas
675		% e.g. x+1 in : s: 1..20 --> (BOOL*(1..20)) & card({x|x|->(TRUE|->x):s})=10 & card({x|x|->(FALSE|->x+1):s})=10
676		constrains_ID_aux(add(A,B),AllParas,P,P,_,_,[]) :- % basically allow other Parameters or ground values
677	?	constrains_ID(A,AllParas,[],[],_,_,_), constrains_ID(B,AllParas,[],[],_,_,_).
678		constrains_ID_aux(minus(A,B),AllParas,P,P,_,_,[]) :- % TO DO: allow other binary/unary operators ?
679		constrains_ID(A,AllParas,[],[],_,_,_), constrains_ID(B,AllParas,[],[],_,_,_).
680		%constrains_ID_aux(Other,All,P,P,_,_,[]) :- print(other(Other)),nl,fail.
681
682		constrains_ID_fields([],_AllParas,P,P,[],[],[]).
683		constrains_ID_fields([field(Field,Val)|TF],AllParas,Parameters,RestParameters,
684		[field(Field,SkelVal)|TSkelV],[field(Field,SkelUnify)|TSkelU],Bind) :-
685	?	constrains_ID(Val,AllParas,Parameters,Rest1,SkelVal,SkelUnify,Bind1),
686	?	constrains_ID_fields(TF,AllParas,Rest1,RestParameters,TSkelV,TSkelU,Bind2),
687		append(Bind1,Bind2,Bind). % TO DO: use DCGs
688
689		:- use_module(custom_explicit_sets,[efficient_card_for_set/3]).
690
691
692		is_small_set(Val,Size,NormalLimit,SMTLimit,SrcLoc) :-
693		get_small_set_size(Val,Size),
694		is_small_size(Size,NormalLimit,SMTLimit,SrcLoc).
695
696		:- use_module(kernel_tools,[ground_value/1]).
697		get_small_set_size(value(S),Size) :- !,
698		ground_value(S), % otherwise we could have S=[X] and expand_quantifier will erroneously create multiple solutions for parameter=X
699		efficient_card_for_set(S,Size,C),
700		call(C).
701		get_small_set_size(interval(From,To),Size) :- !,
702		custom_explicit_sets:is_interval_with_integer_bounds(interval(From,To),Low,Up),
703		number(Low), number(Up),
704		(Low > Up -> Size = 1 ; Size is 1+Up-Low).
705		% we provide dom/ran here explicitly as this is often used {i|i:dom(f) ...}
706		get_small_set_size(bool_set,Size) :- !, Size=2.
707		get_small_set_size(domain(b(Val,_,_)),Size) :- !,
708		get_small_domain_set_size(Val,Size). % this is only an upper bound on the size !!
709		get_small_set_size(range(b(Val,_,_)),Size) :- !,
710		get_small_set_size(Val,Size). % this is only an upper bound on the size !!
711		get_small_set_size(cartesian_product(b(A,_,_),b(B,_,_)),Size) :- !,
712		get_small_set_size(A,SizeA), number(SizeA),
713		get_small_set_size(B,SizeB), number(SizeB),
714		kernel_objects:safe_mul(SizeA,SizeB,Size), number(Size).
715
716		%get_small_set_size(set_extension(L),Size,_,_,_) :- !, length(L,Size), is_small_size(Size). what if elements itself notknown ?? probably the case as otherwise this would have been compiled into a value
717		%get_small_set_size(sequence_extension(L),Size,_,_,_) :- !, length(L,Size), is_small_size(Size). ditto
718		%get_small_set_size(interval...
719		%get_small_set_size(domain(value([....]))...
720		% for this to work efficiently one should call b_compiler:compile on the predicates before sending them
721		% to b_interpreter_check; otherwise the sets will not yet be in value(_) form
722
723		% TO DO: the same for range or find more principled solution
724		%get_small_domain_set_size(value(S),Size) :- var(S), frozen(S,Frozen), print(var_value(S,Frozen)),nl,fail.
725		get_small_domain_set_size(value(Val),Size) :- nonvar(Val), Val=[H|T],!,
726		efficient_card_for_set([H|T],Size,C),
727		ground_domain([H|T]), % rather than requiring ground of entire list; we only require ground for domain (see test 1272)
728		call(C).
729		get_small_domain_set_size(Val,Size) :-
730		get_small_set_size(Val,Size).
731		ground_domain(V) :- var(V),!,fail.
732		ground_domain([]).
733		ground_domain([H|T]) :-
734		nonvar(H), H=(D,_),
735		ground_value(D), ground_domain(T).
736
737		:- use_module(performance_messages).
738		is_small_size(Size,NormalLimit,SMTLimit,SrcLoc) :- Size \= inf,
739		(Size < NormalLimit -> true
740		; preferences:preference(use_smt_mode,true)
741		-> preference(solver_strength,SS),
742		(Size < SMTLimit + SS
743		-> true
744		; perfmessage(reify,'Not reifiying quantifier, try increasing SOLVER_STRENGTH: ','>'(Size,'+'(SMTLimit,SS)),SrcLoc),
745		fail
746		)
747		; perfmessage(reify,'Not reifiying quantifier, try setting SMT preference: ','>'(Size,limit(NormalLimit)),SrcLoc),
748		fail
749		).
750
751		% -------------------------------------
752		% EXPRESSIONS
753
754		:- use_module(store,[set_up_localstate/4]).
755
756		wd_set_up_localstate_for_let(Ids,Exprs,LocalState,State,LetState,WFD) :-
757		set_up_localstate(Ids,Vars,LocalState,LetState),
758		wd_compute_let_expressions(Exprs,Vars,LetState,State,WFD).
759		wd_compute_let_expressions([],[],_,_,_).
760		wd_compute_let_expressions([Expr|RestExprs],[Var|RestVars],LocalState,State,WFD) :-
761		b_wd_compute_expression(Expr,LocalState,State,Value,WFD),
762		kernel_objects:equal_object_optimized(Var,Value,compute_let_expressions),
763		wd_compute_let_expressions(RestExprs,RestVars,LocalState,State,WFD).
764
765
766		% compute a Prolog list of expressions:
767		b_wd_compute_expressions([], _, _, [],_WFD).
768		b_wd_compute_expressions([EXPRsHd|EXPRsTl],LocalState,State,[ValHd|ValTl],WFD) :-
769		b_wd_compute_expression(EXPRsHd,LocalState,State,ValHd,WFD),
770		b_wd_compute_expressions(EXPRsTl,LocalState,State,ValTl,WFD).
771
772		% we have to avoid trying to compute certain expressions: evaluation can fail if not well-defined !
773		b_wd_compute_expression(Expr,LocalState,State,Value,wfwd(WF,WDE,WDV,_)) :- !,
774		(nonvar(WDV)
775		-> (WDE==WDV
776		-> % print('REQUIRED: '), translate:print_bexpr(Expr),nl,
777	?	if(b_compute_expression(Expr,LocalState,State,Value,WF), % TO DO: we could use fresh variable for Value
778		true,
779		(kernel_objects:unbound_value(Value), % we have a WD error, if nonvar it could be because we expect a wrong value
780		add_wd_error_span('Well-definedness error evaluating expression: ',Expr,span_predicate(Expr,LocalState,State),WF)
781		%Value = term(undefined),
782		)
783		)
784		; instantiate_to_any_value(Value,Expr,WF))
785		; always_wd_no_fail_nor_error(Expr)
786		-> % print('ALWAYS WD: '), translate:print_bexpr(Expr),nl, %
787	?	b_compute_expression(Expr,LocalState,State,Value,WF)
788		; b_compiler:b_optimize(Expr,[],LocalState,State,CExpr,WF),
789		% try compiling; this will inline values and may make the expression well_defined; relevant for test 2013
790		(always_wd_no_fail_nor_error(CExpr)
791		% it is important that this computation cannot fail and cannot raise any errors
792		% an example showing this is :wde f=[2,4] & xx:1..3 & (xx=1 or f(xx-1)=4) with -p TRY_FIND_ABORT TRUE
793		% even though the whole expression is well-defined, the function call f(xx-1) does lead
794		% to an error with xx=1
795		-> b_compute_expression(CExpr,LocalState,State,Value,WF)
796		; % print('DELAYING DUE TO WD: '), translate:print_bexpr(CExpr),nl, %%
797		b_compute_expression_delay(WDE,WDV, CExpr,LocalState,State,Value,WF)
798		)
799		).
800		b_wd_compute_expression(Expr,LocalState,State,Value,WFD) :-
801		add_internal_error('Illegal WFD value: ', b_wd_compute_expression(Expr,LocalState,State,Value,WFD)),fail.
802
803
804		always_wd_no_fail_nor_error(Expr) :-
805		always_well_defined(Expr).
806		% should not use always_well_defined_or_disprover_mode or WD discharged information!
807
808		:- block b_compute_expression_delay(?,-, ?,?,?,?,?).
809		b_compute_expression_delay(WDE,WDV,Expr,LocalState,State,Value,WF) :-
810		(WDE==WDV
811		-> % print('WD Evaluation: '), print(WDE),print(' =?= '), print(WDV), print(' '),translate:print_bexpr(Expr),nl,
812		b_compute_expression(Expr,LocalState,State,Value,WF)
813		; %print(instantiate_to_any_value(Value,Expr)),nl,
814		instantiate_to_any_value(Value,Expr,WF) % does not matter anyway; but there can be pending co-routines :-(
815		).
816
817		% WARNING: the variable could be used in another context, where it is relevant !
818
819
820		wd_delay(WDCall,Res, Expr,wfwd(WF,WDExpected,WDV,_)) :-
821		(WDExpected==WDV -> call(WDCall) % WDV truth value on left is ok: we can evaluate
822		; nonvar(WDV) -> instantiate_to_any_value(Res,Expr,WF) % truth value not ok; we do not need the value
823		; always_wd_no_fail_nor_error(Expr) -> call(WDCall)
824		; wd_delay_block(WDCall,Res,Expr,WDExpected,WDV,WF)).
825		:- block wd_delay_block(?,?,?,?,-,?).
826		wd_delay_block(WDCall,Res,Expr,WDExpected,WDV,WF) :-
827		(WDExpected==WDV -> call(WDCall)
828		; instantiate_to_any_value(Res,Expr,WF)).
829
830
831		:- use_module(typing_tools,[any_value_for_type/2]).
832		:- use_module(kernel_tools,[ground_value_check/2]).
833		%instantiate_to_any_value(V,E,_) :- print(instantiate_to_any_value(V)),nl,translate:print_bexpr(E),nl,nl,fail.
834		instantiate_to_any_value(V,_,_) :- ground_value(V),!.
835		instantiate_to_any_value(V,b(_B,TYPE,_I),WF) :-
836		get_enumeration_finished_wait_flag(WF,EWF),
837		ground_value_check(V,GV),
838		blocking_any_value_for_type(EWF,GV,TYPE,V).
839
840		:- block blocking_any_value_for_type(-,-,?,?).
841		blocking_any_value_for_type(_,_,TYPE,V) :- any_value_for_type(TYPE,V). % , print(inst2(TYPE,V)),translate:print_bexpr(b(_B,TYPE,_I)),nl.
842
843
844		:- block propagagate_wfwd(-,?,?,-,?), propagagate_wfwd(?,-,?,-,?).
845		% propagate expected and actual value guarding left with actual predicate value obtained for left
846		propagagate_wfwd(WDE,WDV,Res,F1,F2) :-
847		(F1==F2 -> Res=F1 % then value of WDE does not matter at all; Res always the same
848		; propagagate_wfwd2(WDE,WDV,Res,F1,F2)).
849
850		:- block propagagate_wfwd2(-,?,?,?,?), propagagate_wfwd2(?,-,?,?,?).
851		propagagate_wfwd2(WDE,WDV,Res,F1,F2) :- (WDE==WDV -> Res=F1 ; Res=F2).
852
853		:- use_module(external_functions,[external_fun_has_wd_condition/1]).
854		:- use_module(preferences).
855		b_check_boolean_expression4(exists(Parameters,Body),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,OkToStore,Res) :- !,
856		if(b_check_exists_wfwd(Parameters,Body,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,OkToStore,Res),true,
857		(perfmessagecall(reify,cannot_reify_exists(Parameters),translate:print_bexpr(Body),Body),
858		fail)).
859		b_check_boolean_expression4(Pred,Infos,LocalState,State,WFD,ok_to_store,Res) :-
860	?	b_check_boolean_expression4_ok(Pred,Infos,LocalState,State,WFD,Res).
861
862		b_check_boolean_expression4_ok(equal(LHS,RHS),_,LocalState,State,WFD,EqRes) :- !,
863	?	b_wd_compute_expression(LHS,LocalState,State,LHValue,WFD),
864		b_wd_compute_expression(RHS,LocalState,State,RHValue,WFD),
865		get_texpr_type(LHS,Type), get_wf(WFD,WF),
866		equality_objects_with_type_wf(Type,LHValue,RHValue,EqRes,WF).
867		% we may need to improve not_member for closure to invert symbolic operators
868		b_check_boolean_expression4_ok(member(LHS,RHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :-
869		%member_check_should_be_reified(LHS,RHS), % no longer need this: symbolic operators will be kept as closures if large ?!
870		!,
871		get_texpr_expr(RHS,ERHS),
872	?	b_check_member_expression(ERHS,RHS,LHS,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res).
873		% TO DO: compile forall, exists + setup choice point if expansion fails + remove compile calls in b_interpreter
874		b_check_boolean_expression4_ok(forall(Parameters,LHS,RHS),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :- !,
875	?	if(b_check_forall_wfwd(Parameters,LHS,RHS,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res),true,
876		(perfmessagecall(reify,cannot_reify_forall(Parameters),translate:print_bexpr(LHS),LHS),
877		fail)).
878		b_check_boolean_expression4_ok(subset(LHS,RHS),_,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :- !, get_wf(WFD,WF),
879	?	b_wd_compute_expression(LHS,LocalState,State,LHValue,WFD),
880	?	b_wd_compute_expression(RHS,LocalState,State,RHValue,WFD),
881		subset_test(LHValue,RHValue,Res,WF).
882		b_check_boolean_expression4_ok(subset_strict(LHS,RHS),_,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :- !, get_wf(WFD,WF),
883		b_wd_compute_expression(LHS,LocalState,State,LHValue,WFD),
884		b_wd_compute_expression(RHS,LocalState,State,RHValue,WFD),
885		subset_strict_test(LHValue,RHValue,Res,WF).
886		b_check_boolean_expression4_ok(external_pred_call(FunName,Args),Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :-
887		!,
888		(external_fun_has_wd_condition(FunName)
889		-> wd_delay_until_needed(WFD,b_check_external_pred_call(FunName,Args,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res))
890		; b_check_external_pred_call(FunName,Args,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res)).
891		b_check_boolean_expression4_ok(freetype_case(FT,IsCase,Expr),_Infos,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :- !,
892		b_wd_compute_expression(Expr,LocalState,State,freeval(FT,ActualCase,_A),WFD),
893		eq_atomic(IsCase,ActualCase,freeval_case,Res).
894		b_check_boolean_expression4_ok(finite(Expr),_Infos,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :- !, get_wf(WFD,WF),
895		b_wd_compute_expression(Expr,LocalState,State,ExprVal,WFD),
896		kernel_objects:test_finite_set_wf(ExprVal,Res,WF).
897		b_check_boolean_expression4_ok(partition(Expr,ListOfSets),_Infos,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :- !, get_wf(WFD,WF),
898		b_wd_compute_expression(Expr,LocalState,State,ExprVal,WFD),
899		b_wd_compute_expressions(ListOfSets,LocalState,State,PartitionList,WFD), % arg is a Prolog list, not a set
900	?	kernel_objects:test_partition_wf(ExprVal,PartitionList,Res,WF).
901		b_check_boolean_expression4_ok(Pred,_,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :-
902		arithmetic_op(Pred,Op,LHS,RHS),!,
903	?	b_wd_compute_expression(LHS,LocalState,State,int(LHValue),WFD),
904	?	b_wd_compute_expression(RHS,LocalState,State,int(RHValue),WFD),
905		check_arithmetic_operator(Op,LHValue,RHValue,Res).
906		b_check_boolean_expression4_ok(Pred,_,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :-
907		real_arithmetic_op(Pred,Op,LHS,RHS),!,
908		b_wd_compute_expression(LHS,LocalState,State,LHValue,WFD),
909		b_wd_compute_expression(RHS,LocalState,State,RHValue,WFD),
910		get_wf(WFD,WF),
911		real_comp_wf(Op,LHValue,RHValue,Res,WF).
912		% TO DO ???: use idea of b_artihmetic_expression to avoid intermediate CLPFD variables
913		% TO DO: add other operators, ...
914		/* use_smt_mode = full is never set; at some point we should enable the following clause by default
915		b_check_boolean_expression4_ok(Pred,Infos,LocalState,State,wfwd(WF,WDE,WDV,ContextInfos),Res) :-
916		% preferences:preference(use_smt_mode,full), %% comment out to enable check testing of complicated predicates inside;
917		% caused slowdowns of cbtc/actions_cbtc.mch (test 1751); but no longer the case
918		functor(Pred,F,N),format('~n Cannot reify ~w/~w~n~n',[F,N]),fail,
919		%ContextInfo \= outer_wfwd_context,
920		b_check_boolean_expression4_delay(WDE,WDV,Pred,Infos,LocalState,State,WF,Res).
921		*/
922
923		:- use_module(library(lists),[maplist/3]).
924		% TO DO: add member(,pow_subset, fin_subset) --> subset_test
925		% we could distribute RHS=union -> disjunction, LHS=intersection -> conjunction ,... ?
926		%b_check_member_expression(EHRS,_RHS,_LHS,_,_LocalState,_State,_WFD,_Res) :-
927		% print('member : '), print(EHRS),nl,fail.
928		%b_check_member_expression(union(A,B),LHS,_,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :-
929		b_check_member_expression(pow_subset(RHS),_,LHS,_Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :- !,
930		b_check_boolean_expression4_ok(subset(LHS,RHS),[],LocalState,State,WFD,Res).
931		%b_check_member_expression(NotContainingEmptySet,_TRHS,LHS,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :-
932		% non_empty_set_version_of(NotContainingEmptySet,RHS_With_EmptySet),
933		% % translate x:seq1(RHS) -> x /= {} & x:seq(RHS), ...
934		% % this improves propagation, in particular in light of WD issues
935		% % TO DO: avoid computing LHS twice !
936		% !,
937		% get_texpr_type(LHS,LType),
938		% EMPTYVERSION = b(member(LHS,b(RHS_With_EmptySet,set(LType),[])),pred,[]),
939		% NOTEMPTYPRED = b(not_equal(LHS,b(empty_set,LType,[])),pred,[]),
940		% print('Translating : '), translate:print_bexpr(EMPTYVERSION), print(' & '), translate:print_bexpr(NOTEMPTYPRED),nl,
941		% empty_avl(Ai), Infos=[], % Infos not important for conjunction
942		% b_check_boolean_expression2(conjunct(EMPTYVERSION,NOTEMPTYPRED),Infos,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,_).
943		b_check_member_expression(interval(Low,Up),_,LHS,_Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :- !, get_wf(WFD,WF),
944		% to do: should we also match interval value closure
945		b_wd_compute_expression(LHS,LocalState,State,LHValue,WFD),
946		b_wd_compute_expression(Low,LocalState,State,LowValue,WFD),
947		b_wd_compute_expression(Up,LocalState,State,UpValue,WFD),
948		kernel_objects:test_in_nat_range_wf(LHValue,LowValue,UpValue,Res,WF).
949		b_check_member_expression(set_extension(SetExt),_RHS,LHS,_Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :- !, get_wf(WFD,WF),
950		% rewrite x:{a,b,c} into x=a or x=b or x=c (is the opposite of rewrite_disjunct_to_member)
951		% The rewrite_disjunct_to_member is good when we know a membership to be true; the disjunct is better for reification
952		% Note: the problem is in particular when the result of the membership is not needed and an uninstantiated
953		% variable is used in the set extension, example y:dom(f) => (x:{f(y),0} or f(y)=0)
954		% print(mem_check_set_extension),print(' '),translate:print_bexpr(b(member(LHS,_RHS),pred,[])),nl,
955		b_wd_compute_expressions(SetExt,LocalState,State,SetExtValues,WFD),
956		b_wd_compute_expression(LHS,LocalState,State,LHValue,WFD),
957		get_texpr_type(LHS,Type),
958		NewLHS = b(value(LHValue),Type,[]),
959		(ground_value(SetExtValues)
960		-> % better to use normal treatment, we can compute the entire set and translate it into an AVL tree
961		maplist(construct_value(Type),SetExtValues,Vals),
962		b_wd_compute_expression(b(set_extension(Vals),set(Type),[]),LocalState,State,RHValue,WFD),
963		membership_test_wf(RHValue,LHValue,Res,WF),
964		force_membership_test(Res,LHValue,RHValue,WF)
965		; maplist(construct_equality(NewLHS,Type),SetExtValues,Disjuncts),
966		construct_norm_disjunct2(Disjuncts,NC,InfoNC),
967		empty_avl(Ai),
968		b_check_boolean_expression2(NC,InfoNC,LocalState,State,WFD,Res,Ai,_)
969		).
970		b_check_member_expression(closure(Relation),_RHS,LHS,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :- !, get_wf(WFD,WF),
971		b_wd_compute_expression(LHS,LocalState,State,LHValue,WFD),
972		b_wd_compute_expression(Relation,LocalState,State,RelValue,WFD),
973		opt_push_wait_flag_call_stack_info(WF,b_operator_call(member,
974		[LHValue,b_operator(closure,[RelValue])],Info),WF2), % this is closure1
975		bsets_clp:in_closure1_membership_test_wf(LHValue,RelValue,Res,WF2).
976		b_check_member_expression(partial_function(Dom,Range),_RHS,LHS,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :- !, get_wf(WFD,WF),
977		b_wd_compute_expression(LHS,LocalState,State,LHValue,WFD),
978		b_wd_compute_expression(Dom,LocalState,State,DomValue,WFD),
979		b_wd_compute_expression(Range,LocalState,State,RangeValue,WFD),
980		opt_push_wait_flag_call_stack_info(WF,b_operator_call(member,
981		[LHValue,b_operator(partial_function,[DomValue,RangeValue])],Info),WF2),
982		bsets_clp:partial_function_test_wf(LHValue,DomValue,RangeValue,Res,WF2).
983		b_check_member_expression(total_function(Dom,Range),_RHS,LHS,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :- !, get_wf(WFD,WF),
984		b_wd_compute_expression(LHS,LocalState,State,LHValue,WFD),
985		b_wd_compute_expression(Dom,LocalState,State,DomValue,WFD),
986		b_wd_compute_expression(Range,LocalState,State,RangeValue,WFD),
987		opt_push_wait_flag_call_stack_info(WF,b_operator_call(member,
988		[LHValue,b_operator(total_function,[DomValue,RangeValue])],Info),WF2),
989		bsets_clp:total_function_test_wf(LHValue,DomValue,RangeValue,Res,WF2).
990		b_check_member_expression(partial_surjection(Dom,Range),_RHS,LHS,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :- !, get_wf(WFD,WF),
991		b_wd_compute_expression(LHS,LocalState,State,LHValue,WFD),
992		b_wd_compute_expression(Dom,LocalState,State,DomValue,WFD),
993		b_wd_compute_expression(Range,LocalState,State,RangeValue,WFD),
994		opt_push_wait_flag_call_stack_info(WF,b_operator_call(member,
995		[LHValue,b_operator(partial_surjection,[DomValue,RangeValue])],Info),WF2),
996		bsets_clp:partial_surjection_test_wf(LHValue,DomValue,RangeValue,Res,WF2).
997		b_check_member_expression(seq1(SeqType),_RHS,LHS,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :- !, get_wf(WFD,WF),
998		b_wd_compute_expression(LHS,LocalState,State,LHValue,WFD),
999		b_wd_compute_expression(SeqType,LocalState,State,SeqTValue,WFD),
1000		opt_push_wait_flag_call_stack_info(WF,b_operator_call(member,
1001		[LHValue,b_operator(seq1,[SeqTValue])],Info),WF2),
1002	?	bsets_clp:test_finite_non_empty_sequence(LHValue,SeqTValue,Res,WF2).
1003		% TODO: more sequence checks
1004		b_check_member_expression(_Arg,RHS,LHS,_Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :- get_wf(WFD,WF),
1005		b_wd_compute_expression(LHS,LocalState,State,LHValue,WFD),
1006		b_wd_compute_expression(RHS,LocalState,State,RHValue,WFD),
1007		membership_test_wf(RHValue,LHValue,Res,WF),
1008		%(var(Res) -> add_message(reify,member,LHS,_Info) ; true),
1009		force_membership_test(Res,LHValue,RHValue,WF).
1010
1011		% -------------------------
1012
1013		% wfwd/4 add information about WD context to a WF store: wfwd(WF_store, ExpectedVal, Val,Infos)
1014		% when Val becomes nonvar: if Val==ExpectedVal we need the value of E, otherwise it should be discarded
1015
1016		% get WF store from WFD record
1017		get_wf(wfwd(WF,_,_,_),Res) :- !, Res=WF.
1018		get_wf(WFD,WF) :- add_internal_error('Illegal WFD store: ',get_wf(WFD,WF)),
1019		WF = no_wf_available.
1020
1021		% get expected PredicateResult and actual value; if both identical the associated expression is needed
1022		get_wd(wfwd(_,WDExpected,WDVal,_),WDE,WDV) :- !, (WDExpected,WDVal)=(WDE,WDV).
1023		get_wd(WFWD,WDE,WDV) :- add_internal_error('Illegal WFWD info:',get_wd(WFWD,WDE,WDV)), WDE=pred_true,WDV=pred_true.
1024
1025		% create a WFWF construct for an expression that is needed and where reification should only succeed
1026		% if the top-level construct at least can be fully reified (without non-determinism)
1027		create_wfwd_needed(WF,wfwd(WF,pred_true,pred_true,outer_wfwd_context)).
1028
1029		create_wfwd(WF,WDExpected,WDVal,wfwd(WF,WDExpected,WDVal,inner_wfwd_context)).
1030
1031		:- public portray_wfwd/1.
1032		portray_wfwd(wfwd(_,WDExpected,WDVal,Ctxt)) :-
1033		format('Sub-formula required if ~w is expected ~w (ctxt: ~w)~n',[WDVal,WDExpected,Ctxt]).
1034
1035		% ----------------------
1036
1037		construct_value(Type,Val,b(value(Val),Type,[])).
1038
1039		:- use_module(bsyntaxtree, [safe_create_texpr/3]).
1040		construct_equality(NewLHS,Type,ElementV,Equality) :-
1041		Element = b(value(ElementV),Type,[]),
1042		safe_create_texpr(equal(NewLHS,Element),pred,Equality). %, translate:print_bexpr(Equality),nl.
1043
1044		%non_empty_set_version_of(seq1(RHS),seq(RHS)).
1045		%non_empty_set_version_of(iseq1(RHS),iseq(RHS)).
1046		%non_empty_set_version_of(fin1_subset(RHS),fin_subset(RHS)).
1047		%non_empty_set_version_of(pow1_subset(RHS),pow_subset(RHS)).
1048
1049
1050		:- block b_check_boolean_expression4_delay(?,-,?,?,?,?,?,?).
1051		% currently only used for existential quantified predicates in data_validation_mode
1052		b_check_boolean_expression4_delay(WDE,WDV,_Pred,_Infos,_,_,_WF,Res) :- WDE \= WDV,
1053		% no need to check reify_inner_exists_non_deterministically, as we have marked _Pred as do_not_store
1054		% ignoring (not evaluating) predicate
1055		!,
1056		Res=pred_false. % does not matter here (but Res could have been in another context, see above and test 2404)
1057		b_check_boolean_expression4_delay(_WDE,_WDV,Pred,Infos,LocalState,State,WF,Res) :-
1058		% we currently have not yet implemented a way to check the Pred; wait until Result is known
1059		(preferences:preference(use_smt_mode,false)
1060		-> get_last_wait_flag(b_check_test_boolean_expression,WF,WF2)
1061		; get_binary_choice_wait_flag(b_check_test_boolean_expression,WF,WF2)
1062		),
1063		(debug:debug_mode(on) -> print(' Check Testing: '),translate:print_bexpr(Pred),nl ; true),
1064		b_check_test_boolean_expression(Res,WF2,b(Pred,pred,Infos),LocalState,State,WF).
1065
1066		:- block b_check_test_boolean_expression(-,-,?,?,?,?).
1067		%b_check_test_boolean_expression(P,LWF,Pred,LocalState,State,WF) :- write(check_test4(P,LWF)),nl,fail.
1068		b_check_test_boolean_expression(pred_true,_,Pred,LocalState,State,WF) :-
1069		b_test_boolean_expression(Pred,LocalState,State,WF).
1070		b_check_test_boolean_expression(pred_false,_,Pred,LocalState,State,WF) :-
1071		b_interpreter:b_not_test_boolean_expression(Pred,LocalState,State,WF).
1072
1073
1074		/*
1075		:- use_module(kernel_mappings).
1076		member_check_should_be_reified(_,b(RHS,_,_)) :- functor(RHS,BOP,Arity), print(check(BOP,Arity)),nl,!.
1077		member_check_should_be_reified(_,_) :- \+ preferences:preference(use_smt_mode,false),!.
1078		member_check_should_be_reified(_LHS,b(RHS,_,_)) :- functor(RHS,BOP,Arity),
1079		% check if we have optimized treatments available, for which we do not yet have reified versions
1080		(Arity=1 -> \+ kernel_mappings:unary_in_boolean_type(BOP,_)
1081		; Arity=2 -> \+ kernel_mappings:binary_in_boolean_type(BOP,_)
1082		; Arity=0 -> \+ kernel_mappings:cst_in_boolean_type(BOP,_)
1083		; true).
1084		*/
1085
1086
1087		:- block force_membership_test(-,?,?,?).
1088		% currently required for ensuring that following fails:
1089		% kernel_objects:union(closure(['_zzzz_unit_tests'],[integer],b(member(b(identifier('_zzzz_unit_tests'),integer,[generated]),b(value([int(3),int(4)]),set(integer),[])),pred,[])),closure(['_zzzz_unit_tests'],[integer],b(member(b(identifier('_zzzz_unit_tests'),integer,[generated]),b(value([int(2),int(1)]),set(integer),[])),pred,[])),[int(1),int(3),int(2)])
1090		% Reason: membership_test does not on its own enumerate
1091		force_membership_test(pred_true,X,Set,WF) :-
1092		Set \= [],
1093		(ground_value(X) -> true
1094		; nonvar(Set),no_use_forcing(Set) -> true % no use in forcing membership, will call same element_of_avl_set_wf
1095		; kernel_objects:check_element_of_wf(X,Set,WF)
1096		).
1097		force_membership_test(pred_false,_X,_Set,_WF).
1098
1099		% forcing is sometimes useful because we can transmit a WF, currently some of the reification predicates
1100		% do not have a WF-Store and can thus do limited enumeration ! in particular true for CLPFD = FALSE mode
1101		no_use_forcing(avl_set(_)) :- preferences:preference(use_clpfd_solver,true).
1102		no_use_forcing(global_set(_)).
1103		%no_use_forcing(closure(_,_,B)) :- preferences:preference(use_clpfd_solver,true).
1104
1105
1106
1107		:- use_module(external_functions,[call_external_predicate/8, do_not_evaluate_args/1]).
1108		b_check_external_pred_call(FunName,Args,Info,LocalState,State,WFD,Res) :-
1109		get_wf(WFD,WF),
1110		(do_not_evaluate_args(FunName) -> EvaluatedArgs=[]
1111		; b_wd_compute_expressions(Args, LocalState,State, EvaluatedArgs, WFD)),
1112		push_wait_flag_call_stack_info(WF,external_call(FunName,EvaluatedArgs,Info),WF2),
1113		call_external_predicate(FunName,Args,EvaluatedArgs,LocalState,State,Res,Info,WF2).
1114
1115		wd_delay_until_needed(WFWD,Call) :-
1116		get_wd(WFWD,WDExpected,WDV),
1117		wd_delay_until_needed_block(WDExpected,WDV,Call).
1118		:- block wd_delay_until_needed_block(-,?,?), wd_delay_until_needed_block(?,-,?).
1119		wd_delay_until_needed_block(WDExpected,WDV,Call) :- WDExpected==WDV,!,
1120		call(Call).
1121		wd_delay_until_needed_block(_,_,_). % first call not needed
1122
1123
1124		:- use_module(library(avl)).
1125		reuse_predicate(_,_,no_avl) :- !,fail.
1126		reuse_predicate(Pred,Var,AVL) :-
1127		avl_fetch(Pred,AVL,Var),!. %pred_var(Var)).
1128		reuse_predicate(Pred,Var,AVL) :- %print(check(Pred)),nl, portray_avl(AVL),nl,
1129		preferences:preference(use_smt_mode,true), % it does not seem very expensive; we could always enable it
1130	?	implied_by(Pred,Val,OtherPred,OVal),
1131		avl_fetch(OtherPred,AVL,OVar), OVar==OVal,!,
1132		%print(reused_due_to_implication(Pred)),nl,nl,
1133		Var=Val.
1134
1135		add_predicate(_Pred,_Var,no_avl,NewAVL) :- !, NewAVL=no_avl.
1136		add_predicate(Pred,Var,AVL,NewAVL) :-
1137		% we could compute terms:term_hash(Pred,H) and add pred(H,Pred) to AVL to avoid comparing terms during avl_fetch
1138		(avl_store(Pred,AVL,Var,NewAVL) -> true ; NewAVL=no_avl). %pred_var(Var),NewAVL).
1139
1140		% detect whether predicate implied by some registered predicate
1141		% detects inconsistency in x:INTEGER & x>y & y>x
1142		% very lightweight propagation also achieved by CHR for less
1143		implied_by(less(A,B),pred_false,less(B,A),pred_true). % A>B => not( A<B ) <=> A>=B
1144		implied_by(subset_strict(A,B),pred_false,subset_strict(B,A),pred_true). % B <<: A => not( A<<:B )
1145		implied_by(subset_strict(A,B),pred_false,subset(B,A),pred_true). % B <: A => not( A<<:B )
1146		implied_by(subset(A,B),pred_false,subset_strict(B,A),pred_true). % B <<: A => not( A<:B )
1147		% TO DO: add more rules; e.g., less(x,10) implied by less(x,9)
1148
1149		:- use_module(translate,[print_bexpr/1]).
1150		% normalises a typed predicate by removing position information and ordering commutative operators in a canonical way
1151		norm_pred_check(B,Res) :-
1152		( norm_pred(B,Res)
1153		-> true
1154		; bget_functor(B,F,N),
1155		print(norm_pred_failed(F/N)), nl,
1156		print_bexpr(B), nl,
1157		Res=B
1158		).
1159
1160		bget_functor(b(B,_,_),F,N) :- functor(B,F,N).
1161		bget_functor(B,F,N) :- functor(B,F,N).
1162
1163		%% :-(+List, -UntypedConj).
1164		conjunct_untyped([], Res) :- !, Res=truth.
1165		conjunct_untyped([P|Rest],Result) :- conjunct2(Rest,P,Result).
1166		conjunct2([],P,P).
1167		conjunct2([Q|Rest],P,Result) :- conjunct2(Rest,conjunct(P,Q),Result).
1168
1169		%% disjunct_untyped(+List, -UntypedDisj).
1170		disjunct_untyped([], Res) :- !, Res=falsity.
1171		disjunct_untyped([P|Rest],Result) :- disjunct2(Rest,P,Result).
1172		disjunct2([],P,P).
1173		disjunct2([Q|Rest],P,Result) :- disjunct2(Rest,disjunct(P,Q),Result).
1174
1175		:- assert_must_succeed((I=b(identifier(i),integer,[]),P1=b(greater_equal(I,I),pred,[]),norm_pred(P1,N1),
1176		P2=b(greater_equal(I,I),pred,[info]),norm_pred(P2,N2), N2==N1)). % info ignored
1177		:- assert_must_succeed((I1=b(identifier(i1),integer,[]),I2=b(identifier(i2),integer,[]),
1178		P1=b(equal(I1,I2),pred,[]),norm_pred(P1,N1),
1179		P2=b(equal(I2,I1),pred,[info]),norm_pred(P2,N2), N2==N1)). % equal re-ordered
1180		:- assert_must_succeed((I1=b(identifier(i1),integer,[]),I2=b(identifier(i2),integer,[]),
1181		P1=b(greater_equal(I1,I2),pred,[]),norm_pred(P1,N1),
1182		P2=b(less_equal(I2,I1),pred,[info]),norm_pred(P2,N2), N2==N1)). % <= and >= re-ordered
1183		:- assert_must_succeed((I1=b(identifier(i1),integer,[]),I2=b(identifier(i2),integer,[]),
1184		P1=b(greater(I1,I2),pred,[]),norm_pred(P1,N1),
1185		P2=b(less(I2,I1),pred,[info]),norm_pred(P2,N2), N2==N1)). % < and > re-ordered
1186		:- assert_must_succeed((I1=b(identifier(i1),integer,[]),I2=b(identifier(i2),integer,[]),
1187		P1=b(greater(I1,I2),pred,[]),norm_pred(P1,N1),
1188		P2=b(less_equal(I2,I1),pred,[]),norm_pred(P2,N2), N2 \= N1)). % > and <= not made equal
1189		:- assert_must_succeed((I=b(identifier(i),integer,[]),P1=b(greater_equal(I,I),pred,[was(test1)]),
1190		P2=b(not_equal(I,I),pred,[was(test2)]),
1191		conjunct_predicates_with_pos_info([P1,P2],C1),norm_pred(C1,N1),
1192		conjunct_predicates_with_pos_info([P2,P1],C2),norm_pred(C2,N2), N2==N1)). % conjunct re-ordered
1193		:- assert_must_succeed((I=b(identifier(i),integer,[]),P1=b(greater_equal(I,I),pred,[was(test1)]),
1194		P2=b(not_equal(I,I),pred,[was(test2)]), P3=b(equal(I,I),pred,[was(test3)]),
1195		conjunct_predicates_with_pos_info([P1,P2,P3],C1),norm_pred(C1,N1),
1196		conjunct_predicates_with_pos_info([P2,P3,P1],C2),norm_pred(C2,N2), N2==N1)).
1197
1198		%% norm_pred(+AstOrExpr, -Norm).
1199		norm_pred(X,Res) :- var(X),!,Res=X.
1200		norm_pred(b(B,_,_),Res) :- !, norm_pred(B,Res).
1201		norm_pred(falsity,Res) :- !, Res=falsity.
1202		norm_pred(truth,Res) :- !, Res=truth.
1203		norm_pred(conjunct(A,B),Res) :-
1204		!,
1205		flatten_conjunctions([A,B],CList),
1206		% sort nested conjunctions and disjunctions instead of only single ones
1207		% e.g., difference for '#i.(i : NATURAL & (i > `max`(self) & num′ = num <+ {self |-> i}))' if removing nested parentheses
1208		l_norm_pred(CList, NormedList),
1209		sort(NormedList,SortedList), % better to sort after normalisation
1210		conjunct_untyped(SortedList, Res).
1211		norm_pred(disjunct(A,B),Res) :-
1212		!,
1213		disjunction_to_list(b(disjunct(A,B),pred,[]), CList), % it would be more efficient not to re-construct the b/3 term
1214		l_norm_pred(CList, NormedList),
1215		sort(NormedList,SortedList),
1216		disjunct_untyped(SortedList, Res).
1217		norm_pred(equal(A,B),Res) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA),norm_expr(B,BB),
1218		(BB @< AA -> Res = equal(AA,BB) ; Res= equal(BB,AA)).
1219		norm_pred(equivalence(A,B),Res) :- !, norm_pred(A,AA), norm_pred(B,BB),
1220		(BB @< AA -> Res = equivalence(AA,BB) ; Res= equivalence(BB,AA)).
1221		norm_pred(exists(A,B),Res) :- !, Res=exists(AA,BB),l_norm_expr(A,AA), norm_pred(B,BB).
1222		norm_pred(finite(A),finite(AA)) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA).
1223		norm_pred(forall(A,B,C),Res) :- !, Res=forall(AA,BB,CC),l_norm_expr(A,AA), norm_pred(B,BB), norm_pred(C,CC).
1224		norm_pred(greater(A,B),Less) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA),norm_expr(B,BB), norm_less(BB,AA,Less).
1225		norm_pred(greater_equal(A,B),Leq) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA),norm_expr(B,BB), norm_less_equal(BB,AA,Leq).
1226		norm_pred(implication(A,B),Res) :- !, % we could rewrite this to disjunct(not(A),B); but check ok for WD prover
1227		Res=implication(AA,BB),norm_pred(A,AA), norm_pred(B,BB).
1228		norm_pred(less(A,B),Less) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA),norm_expr(B,BB), norm_less(AA,BB,Less).
1229		norm_pred(less_real(A,B),less_real(AA,BB)) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA),norm_expr(B,BB).
1230		norm_pred(less_equal(A,B),Leq) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA),norm_expr(B,BB), norm_less_equal(AA,BB,Leq).
1231		norm_pred(less_equal_real(A,B),less_equal_real(AA,BB)) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA),norm_expr(B,BB).
1232		norm_pred(let_predicate(A,B,C),Res) :- !,
1233		Res=let_predicate(AA,BB,CC),
1234		l_norm_expr(A,AA), l_norm_expr(B,BB),norm_pred(C,CC).
1235		norm_pred(lazy_let_pred(A,B,C),Res) :- !,
1236		Res = lazy_let_pred(AA,BB,CC),
1237		norm_expr(A,AA),
1238		norm_pred_or_expr(B,BB),norm_pred(C,CC).
1239		norm_pred(lazy_lookup_pred(A),Res) :- !, Res = lazy_lookup_pred(A).
1240		norm_pred(member(A,B),member(AA,BB)) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA),norm_expr(B,BB).
1241		norm_pred(negation(A),Res) :- !,
1242		(negate_typed_pred(A,NegA) -> norm_pred(NegA,Res)
1243		; Res=negation(AA), norm_pred(A,AA)).
1244		norm_pred(not_equal(A,B),Res) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA),norm_expr(B,BB),
1245		(BB @< AA -> Res = not_equal(AA,BB) ; Res= not_equal(BB,AA)).
1246		norm_pred(not_member(A,B),not_member(AA,BB)) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA),norm_expr(B,BB).
1247		norm_pred(not_subset(A,B),not_subset(AA,BB)) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA),norm_expr(B,BB).
1248		norm_pred(not_subset_strict(A,B),not_subset_strict(AA,BB)) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA),norm_expr(B,BB).
1249		norm_pred(partition(A,L),partition(AA,LL)) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA),l_norm_expr(L,LL).
1250		norm_pred(subset(A,B),subset(AA,BB)) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA),norm_expr(B,BB).
1251		norm_pred(subset_strict(A,B),subset_strict(AA,BB)) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA),norm_expr(B,BB).
1252		norm_pred(freetype_case(Type,Case,A),freetype_case(Type,Case,AA)) :- !,norm_expr(A,AA).
1253		norm_pred(X,X). % :- print(norm_pred(X)),nl.
1254
1255
1256		l_norm_pred([],[]).
1257		l_norm_pred([H|T],[NH|NT]) :- norm_pred(H,NH), l_norm_pred(T,NT).
1258
1259		norm_pred_or_expr(b(B,pred,_),Res) :- norm_pred(B,Res).
1260		norm_pred_or_expr(B,Res) :- norm_expr(B,Res).
1261
1262		norm_less(unary_minus(A),MB,Res) :- apply_unary_minus(MB,B), !,norm_less(B,A,Res). % -A < -B => A > B
1263		% we could also move unary_minus to B if not present
1264		norm_less(MA,unary_minus(B),Res) :- apply_unary_minus(MA,A), !,norm_less(B,A,Res).
1265		norm_less(A,B,less(A,B)).
1266
1267		apply_unary_minus(unary_minus(A),A).
1268		apply_unary_minus(Nr,MNr) :- number(Nr), MNr is -Nr.
1269
1270		norm_less_equal(unary_minus(A),MB,Res) :- apply_unary_minus(MB,B), !,norm_less_equal(B,A,Res). % -A <= -B => A >= B
1271		norm_less_equal(MA,unary_minus(B),Res) :- apply_unary_minus(MA,A), !,norm_less_equal(B,A,Res).
1272		norm_less_equal(A,B,less_equal(A,B)).
1273
1274		norm_expr_check(X,Res) :- var(X),!,Res=X.
1275		norm_expr_check(b(B,_,_),Res) :- !, norm_expr_check2(B,Res).
1276		norm_expr_check(X,X).
1277
1278		norm_expr_check2(B,Res) :-
1279		(norm_expr2(B,Res) -> true
1280		; functor(B,F,N),print(norm_expr2_failed(F/N)),nl,
1281		Res=B).
1282
1283		norm_expr(X,Res) :- var(X),!,Res=X.
1284		norm_expr(b(B,_,_),Res) :- !, norm_expr2(B,Res).
1285		%norm_expr_check2(B,Res). %% comment in to obtain details about failed normalisation for expressions
1286		norm_expr(X,X). % :- add_internal_error('Expr not wrapped:',norm_expr(X,X)).
1287
1288		norm_expr2(assertion_expression(Cond,E,Expr),assertion_expression(AA,E,BB)) :- norm_pred(Cond,AA),norm_expr(Expr,BB).
1289		norm_expr2(add(A,B),Res) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB), (BB @< AA -> Res = add(AA,BB) ; Res= add(BB,AA)).
1290		norm_expr2(add_real(A,B),add_real(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1291		norm_expr2(bag_items(A),bag_items(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1292		norm_expr2(boolean_false,boolean_false).
1293		norm_expr2(boolean_true,boolean_true).
1294		norm_expr2(bool_set,bool_set).
1295		norm_expr2(card(A),card(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1296		norm_expr2(cartesian_product(A,B),cartesian_product(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1297		norm_expr2(closure(A),closure(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA). % this is closure1
1298		norm_expr2(compaction(A),compaction(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1299		norm_expr2(composition(A,B),composition(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1300		norm_expr2(comprehension_set(A,B),comprehension_set(AA,BB)) :- l_norm_expr(A,AA), norm_pred(B,BB).
1301		norm_expr2(concat(A,B),concat(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1302		norm_expr2(convert_bool(A),convert_bool(AA)) :- norm_pred_check(A,AA).
1303		norm_expr2(convert_real(A),convert_real(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1304		norm_expr2(convert_int_floor(A),convert_int_floor(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1305		norm_expr2(convert_int_ceiling(A),convert_int_ceiling(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1306		norm_expr2(couple(A,B),couple(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1307		norm_expr2(direct_product(A,B),direct_product(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1308		norm_expr2(div(A,B),div(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1309		norm_expr2(div_real(A,B),div_real(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1310		norm_expr2(floored_div(A,B),floored_div(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1311		norm_expr2(domain_restriction(A,B),domain_restriction(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1312		norm_expr2(domain_subtraction(A,B),domain_subtraction(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1313		norm_expr2(domain(A),domain(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1314		norm_expr2(empty_sequence,empty_sequence).
1315		norm_expr2(empty_set,empty_set).
1316		norm_expr2(event_b_identity,event_b_identity).
1317		norm_expr2(external_function_call(A,B),external_function_call(A,BB)) :- l_norm_expr(B,BB).
1318		norm_expr2(fin_subset(A),fin_subset(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1319		norm_expr2(fin1_subset(A),fin1_subset(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1320		norm_expr2(first(A),first(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1321		norm_expr2(first_of_pair(A),first_of_pair(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1322		norm_expr2(first_projection(A,B),first_projection(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1323		norm_expr2(float_set,float_set).
1324		norm_expr2(front(A),front(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1325		norm_expr2(function(A,B),function(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1326		norm_expr2(general_concat(A),general_concat(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1327		norm_expr2(general_intersection(A),general_intersection(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1328		norm_expr2(general_product(A,B,C),Res) :- !,
1329		Res=general_product(AA,BB,CC),l_norm_expr(A,AA), norm_pred(B,BB), norm_expr(C,CC).
1330		norm_expr2(general_sum(A,B,C),Res) :- !,
1331		Res=general_sum(AA,BB,CC),l_norm_expr(A,AA), norm_pred(B,BB), norm_expr(C,CC).
1332		norm_expr2(general_union(A),general_union(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1333		norm_expr2(identifier(A),'$'(A)). % need wrapper to avoid confusion with other terms !
1334		norm_expr2(identity(A),identity(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1335		norm_expr2(if_then_else(P,A,B),if_then_else(PP,AA,BB)) :- norm_pred(P,PP),norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1336		norm_expr2(image(A,B),image(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1337		norm_expr2(insert_front(A,B),insert_front(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1338		norm_expr2(insert_tail(A,B),insert_tail(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1339		norm_expr2(integer_set(A),A).
1340		norm_expr2(integer(A),A). % integer represented as number
1341		norm_expr2(intersection(A,B),Res) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB),
1342		(BB @< AA -> Res = intersection(AA,BB) ; Res= intersection(BB,AA)).
1343		norm_expr2(interval(A,B),interval(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1344		norm_expr2(iseq(A),iseq(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1345		norm_expr2(iseq1(A),iseq1(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1346		norm_expr2(iteration(A,B),iteration(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1347		norm_expr2(last(A),last(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1348		norm_expr2(lazy_let_expr(A,B,C),lazy_let_expr(AA,BB,CC)) :-
1349		norm_expr(A,AA),norm_pred_or_expr(B,BB),norm_expr(C,CC).
1350		norm_expr2(lazy_lookup_expr(A),lazy_lookup_expr(A)) :- !.
1351		norm_expr2(let_expression(A,B,C),let_expression(AA,BB,CC)) :- l_norm_expr(A,AA), l_norm_expr(B,BB),norm_expr(C,CC).
1352		norm_expr2(let_expression_global(A,B,C),let_expression_global(AA,BB,CC)) :- l_norm_expr(A,AA), l_norm_expr(B,BB),norm_pred(C,CC).
1353		norm_expr2(max(A),max(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1354		norm_expr2(max_real(A),max_real(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1355		norm_expr2(max_int,max_int).
1356		norm_expr2(min(A),min(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1357		norm_expr2(min_real(A),min_real(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1358		norm_expr2(min_int,min_int).
1359		norm_expr2(minus(A,B),minus(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1360		norm_expr2(minus_real(A,B),minus_real(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1361		norm_expr2(modulo(A,B),modulo(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1362		norm_expr2(mu(A),mu(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1363		norm_expr2(multiplication(A,B),Res) :-
1364		norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB), (BB @< AA -> Res = multiplication(AA,BB) ; Res= multiplication(BB,AA)).
1365		norm_expr2(multiplication_real(A,B),multiplication_real(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1366		norm_expr2(operation_call_in_expr(A,B),operation_call_in_expr(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1367		norm_expr2(overwrite(A,B),overwrite(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1368		norm_expr2(parallel_product(A,B),parallel_product(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1369		norm_expr2(partial_bijection(A,B),partial_bijection(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1370		norm_expr2(partial_function(A,B),partial_function(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1371		norm_expr2(partial_injection(A,B),partial_injection(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1372		norm_expr2(partial_surjection(A,B),partial_surjection(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1373		norm_expr2(perm(A),perm(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1374		norm_expr2(power_of(A,B),power_of(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1375		norm_expr2(power_of_real(A,B),power_of_real(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1376		norm_expr2(pow_subset(A),pow_subset(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1377		norm_expr2(pow1_subset(A),pow1_subset(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1378		norm_expr2(predecessor,predecessor).
1379		norm_expr2(range_restriction(A,B),range_restriction(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1380		norm_expr2(range_subtraction(A,B),range_subtraction(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1381		norm_expr2(range(A),range(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1382		norm_expr2(real(Atom),real(Atom)). % we could use the atom? or convert it to a real number using construct_real
1383		norm_expr2(real_set,real_set).
1384		norm_expr2(rec(A),rec(AA)) :- norm_fields(A,AA).
1385		norm_expr2(record_field(A,Field),record_field(AA,Field)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1386		norm_expr2(relations(A,B),relations(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1387		norm_expr2(restrict_front(A,B),restrict_front(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1388		norm_expr2(restrict_tail(A,B),restrict_tail(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1389		norm_expr2(reflexive_closure(A),reflexive_closure(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA). % this is rewritten in ast_cleanup
1390		norm_expr2(rev(A),rev(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1391		norm_expr2(reverse(A),reverse(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1392		norm_expr2(second_of_pair(A),second_of_pair(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1393		norm_expr2(second_projection(A,B),second_projection(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1394		norm_expr2(seq(A),seq(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1395		norm_expr2(seq1(A),seq1(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1396		norm_expr2(sequence_extension(L),sequence_extension(NL)) :- l_norm_expr(L,NL).
1397		norm_expr2(set_extension(L),set_extension(NL)) :- l_norm_expr(L,NL).
1398		norm_expr2(set_subtraction(A,B),set_subtraction(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB). % set difference
1399		norm_expr2(size(A),size(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1400		norm_expr2(string(A),string(A)). % need wrapper to avoid confusion with other terms !
1401		norm_expr2(string_set,string_set).
1402		norm_expr2(struct(A),struct(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1403		norm_expr2(successor,successor).
1404		norm_expr2(surjection_relation(A,B),surjection_relation(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1405		norm_expr2(tail(A),tail(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1406		norm_expr2(total_bijection(A,B),total_bijection(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1407		norm_expr2(total_function(A,B),total_function(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1408		norm_expr2(total_injection(A,B),total_injection(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1409		norm_expr2(total_relation(A,B),total_relation(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1410		norm_expr2(total_surjection(A,B),total_surjection(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1411		norm_expr2(total_surjection_relation(A,B),total_surjection_relation(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB).
1412		norm_expr2(typeset,typeset).
1413
1414		norm_expr2(unary_minus(A),unary_minus(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1415		norm_expr2(unary_minus_real(A),unary_minus_real(AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1416		norm_expr2(union(A,B),Res) :- norm_expr(A,AA), norm_expr(B,BB), (BB @< AA -> Res = union(AA,BB) ; Res= union(BB,AA)).
1417		norm_expr2(value(A),NA) :- norm_value(A,NA).
1418
1419		norm_expr2(freetype_set(T),freetype_set(T)).
1420		norm_expr2(freetype_constructor(FT,Case,A), freetype_constructor(FT,Case,AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1421		norm_expr2(freetype_destructor(FT,Case,A),freetype_destructor(FT,Case,AA)) :- norm_expr(A,AA).
1422		norm_expr2(recursive_let(A,B),recursive_let(AA,BB)) :- norm_expr(A,AA),norm_expr(B,BB).
1423
1424
1425		norm_fields([],[]).
1426		norm_fields([field(Name,H)|T],[field(Name,NH)|NT]) :- norm_expr(H,NH), norm_fields(T,NT).
1427
1428		l_norm_expr([],[]).
1429		l_norm_expr([H|T],[NH|NT]) :- norm_expr(H,NH), l_norm_expr(T,NT).
1430
1431		norm_value(V,R) :- var(V),!,R=value(V).
1432		norm_value(int(Nr),R) :- number(Nr),!,R=Nr.
1433		norm_value([],R) :- !, R=empty_set.
1434		norm_value(pred_false,R) :- !, R=boolean_false.
1435		norm_value(pred_true,R) :- !, R=boolean_true.
1436		norm_value(closure(P,T,B),R) :- norm_pred_check(B,NB),
1437		!, % normalising relevant for test 1544 with position info added by construct_member_closure
1438		R=value(closure(P,T,NB)).
1439		norm_value((A,B),R) :- !, R=(NA,NB), norm_value(A,NA), norm_value(B,NB).
1440		norm_value(V,value(V)). % we could normalise AVL, or pairs
1441
1442		arithmetic_op(less(LHS,RHS),'<',LHS,RHS).
1443		arithmetic_op(less_equal(LHS,RHS),'<=',LHS,RHS).
1444		arithmetic_op(greater(LHS,RHS),'<',RHS,LHS).
1445		arithmetic_op(greater_equal(LHS,RHS),'<=',RHS,LHS).
1446
1447		:- use_module(probsrc(kernel_reals),[real_comp_wf/5]).
1448		% these two predicates can be checked by real_comp_wf:
1449		real_arithmetic_op(less_real(LHS,RHS),'<',LHS,RHS).
1450		real_arithmetic_op(less_equal_real(LHS,RHS),'=<',LHS,RHS).
1451
1452		:- use_module(clpfd_interface).
1453		:- use_module(library(clpfd), [(#<=>)/2]).
1454		check_arithmetic_operator('<',X,Y,Res) :- check_less(X,Y,Res),
1455		(nonvar(Res) -> true
1456		; clpfd_interface:try_post_constraint((X#<Y) #<=> R01), prop_pred_01(Res,R01)).
1457		check_arithmetic_operator('<=',X,Y,Res) :- check_less_than_equal(X,Y,Res),
1458		(nonvar(Res) -> true
1459		; clpfd_interface:try_post_constraint((X#=<Y) #<=> R01), prop_pred_01(Res,R01)).
1460
1461
1462		:- block prop_pred_01(-,-).
1463		prop_pred_01(A,B) :- B==1,!,A=pred_true. % cut ok: either pred_true or 1 set
1464		prop_pred_01(pred_true,1).
1465		prop_pred_01(pred_false,0).
1466
1467		:- block check_less(-,?,-), check_less(?,-,-).
1468		check_less(X,Y,Res) :- nonvar(Res),!, /* truth value known: enforce it */
1469		(Res=pred_true -> less_than_direct(X,Y) ; less_than_equal_direct(Y,X)).
1470		check_less(X,Y,Res) :-
1471		X < Y,!,/* we could call safe_less_than(X,Y), */
1472		Res=pred_true.
1473		check_less(_,_,pred_false).
1474		:- block check_less_than_equal(-,?,-), check_less_than_equal(?,-,-).
1475		check_less_than_equal(X,Y,Res) :- nonvar(Res),!, /* truth value known: enforce it */
1476		(Res=pred_true -> less_than_equal_direct(X,Y) ; less_than_direct(Y,X)).
1477		check_less_than_equal(X,Y,Res) :- X =< Y,!,Res=pred_true.
1478		check_less_than_equal(_,_,pred_false).
1479
1480
1481
1482		:- use_module(bool_pred).
1483
1484		:- use_module(kernel_objects,[exhaustive_kernel_check_wf/2,
1485		exhaustive_kernel_check/1, exhaustive_kernel_check/2, exhaustive_kernel_fail_check/1]).
1486
1487		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_check_wf(b_interpreter_check:conjoin(pred_false,pred_false,pred_false,b(truth,pred,[]),b(truth,pred,[]),WF),WF)).
1488		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_check_wf(b_interpreter_check:conjoin(pred_false,pred_true,pred_false,b(truth,pred,[]),b(truth,pred,[]),WF),WF)).
1489		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_check_wf(b_interpreter_check:conjoin(pred_true,pred_false,pred_false,b(truth,pred,[]),b(truth,pred,[]),WF),WF)).
1490		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_check_wf(b_interpreter_check:conjoin(pred_true,pred_true,pred_true,b(truth,pred,[]),b(truth,pred,[]),WF),WF)).
1491		:- assert_must_fail(b_interpreter_check:conjoin(pred_true,pred_false,pred_true,b(truth,pred,[]),b(truth,pred,[]),_WF)).
1492		:- assert_must_fail(b_interpreter_check:conjoin(pred_true,pred_true,pred_false,b(truth,pred,[]),b(truth,pred,[]),_WF)).
1493
1494
1495		% same as and_equality/3 but for pred_false/pred_true rather than eq_obj/pred_false
1496		:- block conjoin(-,-,-,?,?,?).
1497		conjoin(X,Y,Res,LHS,RHS,WF) :- % print(conjoin(X,Y,Res)),nl, translate:print_bexpr(LHS),nl,%
1498		( Res==pred_true -> X=pred_true,Y=pred_true % on SWI these propagations happen one after the other, see test 2202
1499		; X==pred_true -> Res=Y
1500		; X==pred_false -> Res=pred_false
1501		; Y==pred_true -> Res=X
1502		; Y==pred_false -> Res=pred_false
1503	?	; Res==pred_false -> conjoin_false0(X,Y,LHS,RHS,WF)
1504		; add_error_fail(conjoin,'Illegal values: ', conjoin(X,Y,Res,LHS,RHS,WF))
1505		).
1506		conjoin_false0(X,Y,_LHS,_RHS,_WF) :- X==Y,!,
1507		%print(conjoin_false_eqeq(X,Y)),nl, translate:print_bexpr(_LHS),nl,
1508		X=pred_false.
1509		conjoin_false0(X,Y,_LHS,_RHS,_WF) :- % X & not(X) -> always false
1510		bool_negate_check(X,Y),!
1511		. %,print(conjoin_false_neqeq(X,Y)),nl,translate:print_bexpr(_LHS),nl.
1512		conjoin_false0(X,Y,LHS,RHS,WF) :-
1513		%%Prio=1, %%
1514		%%(preferences:preference(use_smt_mode,full) -> FullPrio=1.5 ;
1515		get_priority_of_boolean_expression(LHS,Prio),
1516		(preferences:preference(use_clpfd_solver,true) ->
1517		% relevant for tests 349, 362:
1518		count_number_of_conjuncts(RHS,NrC),
1519		FullPrio is Prio+(NrC-1)/10,
1520		get_wait_flag(FullPrio,conjoin,WF,LWF) %%
1521		; % in non-clpfd mode: much less propagation going on, avoid explosion of choice points
1522		% tests 349, 362 fail with the following for CLPFD: TO DO investigate and use this also in CLPFD mode
1523		get_binary_choice_wait_flag_exp_backoff(Prio,not_conjunct,WF,LWF)
1524		),
1525	?	conjoin_false(X,Y,LHS,RHS,LWF).
1526		% missing rule: if X==Y -> X=pred_true
1527		:- block conjoin_false(-,-,?,?,-).
1528		conjoin_false(X,Y,LHS,_RHS,_LWF) :-
1529		( X==pred_true -> pred_false=Y
1530		; X==pred_false -> true
1531		; Y==pred_true -> pred_false=X
1532		; Y==pred_false -> true
1533		; useless_to_force(LHS) ->
1534		( % print(forcing_conjoin_rhs_false(X,Y,_LWF)), translate:print_bexpr(_RHS), print(' == FALSE '),nl,
1535		Y=pred_false
1536		;
1537		(Y,X)=(pred_true,pred_false)
1538		)
1539		; ( % print(forcing_conjoin_lhs_false(X,Y,_LWF)), translate:print_bexpr(LHS), print(' == FALSE '),nl,
1540		X=pred_false
1541		; % print(forcing_conjoin_rhs_false(X,Y,_LWF)), translate:print_bexpr(LHS), print(' == TRUE ; '), nl,
1542		(X,Y)=(pred_true,pred_false)
1543		)
1544		).
1545
1546		% determine when forcing a predicate to true/false does not really help; better choose something else
1547		useless_to_force(b(B,T,I)) :- useless_to_force3(B,T,I).
1548		useless_to_force3(finite(_),_,_). % forcing finite to be false usually not a good idea; we cannot propagate this
1549		% what are other predicates useless to force: some foralls/exists ? some external_pred_call
1550		% in principle a conjunction of useless predicates is also useless: but could be more expensive to check
1551
1552		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_check(b_interpreter_check:disjoin(pred_false,pred_false,pred_false,_,_,_WF))).
1553		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_check([commutative],b_interpreter_check:disjoin(pred_false,pred_true,pred_true,_,_,_WF))).
1554		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_check(b_interpreter_check:disjoin(pred_true,pred_true,pred_true,_,_,_WF))).
1555		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_fail_check(b_interpreter_check:disjoin(pred_true,pred_true,pred_false,_,_,_WF))).
1556		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_fail_check(b_interpreter_check:disjoin(pred_true,pred_false,pred_false,_,_,_WF))).
1557		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_fail_check(b_interpreter_check:disjoin(pred_false,pred_true,pred_false,_,_,_WF))).
1558		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_fail_check(b_interpreter_check:disjoin(pred_false,pred_false,pred_true,_,_,_WF))).
1559
1560		:- block disjoin(-,-,-,?,?,?).
1561		disjoin(X,Y,Res,LHS,RHS,WF) :-
1562		%print(disjoin(X,Y,Res,WF)),nl, %% translate:print_bexpr(LHS),print(' or '),translate:print_bexpr(RHS),nl,%%
1563		( Res==pred_false -> X=pred_false,Y=pred_false
1564		; X==pred_true -> Res=pred_true
1565		; X==pred_false -> Res=Y
1566		; Y==pred_true -> Res=pred_true
1567		; Y==pred_false -> Res=X
1568	?	; Res==pred_true -> disjoin_true0(X,Y,LHS,RHS,WF)
1569		; add_error_fail(disjoin,'Illegal values: ',disjoin(X,Y,Res,LHS,RHS,WF))
1570		).
1571		disjoin_true0(X,Y,_LHS,_RHS,_WF) :- X==Y,!,
1572		X=pred_true.
1573		%disjoin_true0(X,Y,LHS,_,WF) :- !, disjoin_true(X,Y,_).
1574		disjoin_true0(X,Y,_LHS,_RHS,_WF) :- % X or not(X) -> always true
1575		bool_negate_check(X,Y),!.
1576
1577		disjoin_true0(X,Y,LHS,_RHS,WF) :-
1578		%%(preferences:preference(use_smt_mode,full) -> FullPrio=2.5 ;
1579		% poses problem for test 1096:
1580		% count_number_of_disjuncts(RHS,NrC),
1581		%FullPrio is Prio+(NrC-1)/10,
1582		%get_wait_flag(FullPrio,disjoin,WF,LWF), %%
1583		get_priority_of_boolean_expression(LHS,StartPrio),
1584		get_binary_choice_wait_flag_exp_backoff(StartPrio,disjunct,WF,LWF),
1585		% TO DO: extract FD information from LHS and RHS and assert, e.g. x:1..2 or x:4..5
1586	?	disjoin_true(X,Y,LHS,LWF).
1587		% missing rule: if X==Y -> X=pred_true ; if X==~Y -> no need to setup choice point
1588		:- block disjoin_true(-,-,?,-).
1589		disjoin_true(X,Y,LHS,_LWF) :-
1590		( X==pred_true -> true
1591		; X==pred_false -> pred_true=Y
1592		; Y==pred_true -> true
1593		; Y==pred_false -> pred_true=X
1594		; useless_to_force(LHS) ->
1595		( %% print(forcing_disjoin_true(X,Y,_LWF)),nl, %%
1596		Y=pred_true
1597		;
1598		%%print(forcing_disjoin_false(X,Y,_LWF)),nl,
1599		(Y,X) = (pred_false,pred_true) % these two unifications will happen atomically !
1600		)
1601		; ( %% print(forcing_disjoin_true(X,Y,_LWF)),nl, %%
1602		X=pred_true
1603		;
1604		%%print(forcing_disjoin_false(X,Y,_LWF)),nl,
1605		(X,Y) = (pred_false,pred_true) % these two unifications will happen atomically !
1606		)
1607		%add_error_fail(disjoin_true,'Illegal values: ',disjoin_true(X,Y))
1608		).
1609
1610		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_check(b_interpreter_check:imply(pred_false,pred_false,pred_true))).
1611		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_check(b_interpreter_check:imply(pred_false,pred_true,pred_true))).
1612		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_check(b_interpreter_check:imply(pred_true,pred_false,pred_false))).
1613		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_check(b_interpreter_check:imply(pred_true,pred_true,pred_true))).
1614		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_fail_check(b_interpreter_check:imply(pred_false,pred_false,pred_false))).
1615		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_fail_check(b_interpreter_check:imply(pred_false,pred_true,pred_false))).
1616		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_fail_check(b_interpreter_check:imply(pred_true,pred_false,pred_true))).
1617		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_fail_check(b_interpreter_check:imply(pred_true,pred_true,pred_false))).
1618
1619		imply(X,Y,Res) :-
1620		(var(X),var(Y),var(Res) -> bool_equality(X,Y,EqXY) ; true /* impl4 will not block anyway */),
1621		impl4(X,Y,EqXY,Res).
1622		:- block impl4(-,-,-,-).
1623		impl4(X,Y,EqXY,Res) :-
1624		( Res==pred_false -> X=pred_true,Y=pred_false
1625		; Res==pred_true -> imply_true3(X,Y,EqXY)
1626		; X==pred_false -> Res=pred_true
1627		; X==pred_true -> Res=Y
1628		; Y==pred_true -> Res=pred_true
1629		; Y==pred_false -> negate(X,Res)
1630		; EqXY==pred_true -> Res=pred_true % X => X is always true
1631		; EqXY==pred_false -> Y=Res % not(Y) => Y is true iff Y is true
1632		; add_error_fail(impl,'Illegal values: ',imply(X,Y,EqXY,Res))
1633		).
1634
1635		% assert X=pred_true => Y=pred_true
1636		imply_true(X,Y) :-
1637		(var(X),var(Y) -> bool_equality(X,Y,EqXY) ; true /* imply_true will not block anyway */),
1638	?	imply_true3(X,Y,EqXY).
1639		:- block imply_true3(-,-,-).
1640		imply_true3(X,Y,EqXY) :-
1641		( X==pred_false -> true
1642		; X==pred_true -> Y=pred_true
1643		; Y==pred_true -> true
1644		; Y==pred_false -> X=pred_false
1645		; EqXY==pred_true -> true
1646		; EqXY==pred_false -> X=pred_false % X => not(X) ===> X=pred_false
1647		; add_error_fail(imply_true,'Illegal values: ',imply_true3(X,Y,EqXY))
1648		).
1649
1650
1651		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_check(b_interpreter_check:equiv(pred_false,pred_false,pred_true))).
1652		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_check(b_interpreter_check:equiv(pred_false,pred_true,pred_false))).
1653		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_check(b_interpreter_check:equiv(pred_true,pred_false,pred_false))).
1654		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_check(b_interpreter_check:equiv(pred_true,pred_true,pred_true))).
1655		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_fail_check(b_interpreter_check:equiv(pred_false,pred_false,pred_false))).
1656		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_fail_check(b_interpreter_check:equiv(pred_false,pred_true,pred_true))).
1657		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_fail_check(b_interpreter_check:equiv(pred_true,pred_false,pred_true))).
1658		:- assert_must_succeed(exhaustive_kernel_fail_check(b_interpreter_check:equiv(pred_true,pred_true,pred_false))).
1659
1660		% b_interpreter_check:equiv(X,Y,Res),X=Y, Res==pred_true
1661		equiv(X,Y,Res) :-
1662		bool_equality(X,Y,Res).
1663
1664